Face to Face with Christ, My Savior Meaning, History, and Theology
"Face to face with Christ, my Savior"
- Written
- 1898
- Category
- Hymn
- Status
- Published
- Rights
- Public domain
Viewed 74 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
Carrie Ellis Breck's 1898 gospel hymn, set to Grant Colfax Tullar's FACE TO FACE, centers on the Christian hope of seeing Christ directly. Rooted especially in 1 Corinthians 13:12, it joins assurance, eternal life, consolation, and eschatological communion with the Redeemer.
Overview
Carrie Ellis Breck's 1898 gospel hymn is a meditation on the Christian hope of seeing Christ without the limitations that characterize present life. Its central biblical image comes from 1 Corinthians 13:12, where partial sight and knowledge give way to direct encounter. Breck turns that contrast into a song of anticipation, assurance, and personal devotion.
The hymn's pastoral strength is its Christ-centered understanding of the future. The believer's hope is not simply survival after death or escape from present difficulty; it is communion with the Redeemer. Other biblical themes associated with the hymn include Christ's appearing, freedom from sorrow, the final vision of God's servants, and the promise that Christ receives his people to himself.
Because of that emphasis, the hymn has been used in settings concerned with eternal life, funerals, memorials, the second coming, and assurance. Its gospel-song form gives a congregation a repeated musical statement of hope while the stanzas move from present limitation toward the promised presence of Christ.
Historical Background
Carrie Ellis Breck wrote the text in 1898 while living in Vineland, New Jersey. Hymnary dates the words to that year, and the Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology identifies 1 Corinthians 13:12 as the hymn's principal biblical source. Breck was a prolific writer of devotional verse who regularly sent texts to gospel-song composers and publishers.
Grant Colfax Tullar's tune has an unusually well-documented origin story, but it is important to describe the evidence accurately. In his 1937 autobiographical book Written Because--, Tullar recalled that during an evangelistic campaign in Rutherford, New Jersey, an almost-empty jelly dish prompted the phrase that inspired him to write a different gospel text and its melody. He sang that first song at an evening meeting and planned to improve its words.
According to Tullar's later account, Breck's poems arrived by mail the next morning. One of them matched the meter of the melody he had just composed, so he discarded his own words and joined Breck's text to the tune. Because this colorful story comes from Tullar himself decades after the event, it is stronger than anonymous tradition but is still a retrospective autobiographical recollection rather than a contemporary 1898 diary or newspaper report.
The Canterbury Dictionary, citing Joseph A. Conwell's 1916 history of First Presbyterian Church in Vineland, reports that the completed hymn was first sung by Tullar in front of the pulpit there. This local evidence also fits Breck's documented connection with the Vineland Presbyterian community. The exact sequence between the Rutherford composition episode and the Vineland performance is not described in every surviving source, so the two events should not be collapsed into one location.
The first securely identified publication is Sermons in Song No. 2, edited by Tullar and Isaac H. Meredith and issued by the Tullar-Meredith Company in 1899. The hymn appears there as no. 4, with Breck credited under the married form Mrs. Frank A. Breck and Tullar credited as composer. The text and its tune therefore entered print as a matched pair almost immediately after their 1898 creation.
Hymnary now indexes the text in more than two hundred seventy hymnals and the tune in more than two hundred fifty, including Baptist, Adventist, Methodist, African Methodist Episcopal, Mennonite, and other Protestant collections. Translations include Spanish, French, Swahili, Portuguese, Chinese, and additional languages. The 1898 text and tune and the 1899 first identified publication are public domain in the United States; later translations, arrangements, harmonizations, and recordings may have separate rights.
Biblical Foundations
First Corinthians 13:12 is the hymn's clearest biblical foundation. Paul's contrast between present indirect perception and future direct encounter gives Breck both the controlling image and the emotional movement of the song. Christian hope is represented as a transition from partial knowledge toward fuller communion in God's presence.
First John 3:2 adds an explicitly Christological dimension by linking the believer's future transformation with seeing Christ as he is when he is revealed. Revelation 22:4-5 extends the theme into the final biblical vision of God's servants seeing the divine face and living in God's unending light.
Revelation 21:4 provides the pastoral setting for the end of grief, death, crying, and pain, while John 14:2-3 centers the believer's future on Christ's promise to receive his people to himself. Taken together, these passages support the hymn's emphasis on sight, presence, transformation, consolation, and eternal fellowship without requiring every poetic detail to be treated as a direct quotation of Scripture.
Verse Explanation
The hymn begins with wonder about the believer's future encounter with Christ. Rather than describing heaven in detail, the opening movement fixes attention on the Savior and on the difference between present faith and future sight.
The next movement acknowledges the limitations of present perception while expressing confidence that those limitations are temporary. The emphasis is not on possessing exhaustive answers now but on trusting the promised revelation of Christ.
A third movement turns toward consolation, envisioning a future in which present grief and confusion no longer dominate human experience. The song therefore gives suffering an eschatological horizon without pretending that pain is already absent.
The final movement gathers the hymn into personal communion with the Redeemer. The recurring refrain reinforces the same central hope throughout, giving congregational singers a repeated confession that the Christian future is ultimately centered on Christ himself.
Theological Reflection
The hymn's principal doctrine is eschatological communion with Christ. Christian hope is not merely about a future place but about the unveiled presence of the Savior. The longing to see Christ gives personal focus to doctrines of resurrection, eternal life, and the consummation of salvation.
A second theme is the contrast between present limitation and future fullness. First Corinthians 13 places human knowledge in the present age under the sign of incompleteness. The hymn therefore offers a useful spirituality of humility: believers can trust Christ even while many questions remain unresolved.
The song also functions pastorally as a theology of consolation. Scripture does not promise that believers will avoid grief or pain now, but Revelation 21 locates those realities within a future in which death and sorrow no longer rule. Christian assurance is thus grounded in God's promised future rather than in denial of present suffering.
Finally, the hymn's hope is inseparable from redemption. The Christ whom believers expect to see is the Redeemer whose saving work establishes their hope. In worship, this keeps reflection on heaven centered on Christ rather than on speculation about details Scripture does not disclose.
Church Impact
Hymnary documents the text in more than two hundred seventy hymnals, showing broad transmission through twentieth- and twenty-first-century evangelical and Protestant worship. It appears in Baptist, Seventh-day Adventist, African Methodist Episcopal, Mennonite, Churches of Christ, holiness, and other collections, often under subjects such as eternal life, heaven, assurance, the second coming, or fellowship with Christ.
The hymn also crossed linguistic boundaries. Hymnary records Spanish and French translations and additional instances in languages including Swahili, Portuguese, Chinese, and others. Such evidence demonstrates international hymnal transmission, although inclusion in a book does not by itself establish how frequently each translation was sung.
Its continuing pastoral use is understandable from the union of a simple gospel melody with a concentrated biblical image. The hymn gives congregations language for hope in the presence of death, grief, incomplete understanding, and longing for Christ, while remaining specific enough to be rooted in recognizable New Testament promises.
Musical Notes
FACE TO FACE was composed by Grant Colfax Tullar in 1898 and is historically bound to Breck's text from the hymn's earliest publication. Hymnary gives the tune's meter as 8.7.8.7 with refrain and indexes it in more than two hundred fifty hymnals.
Tullar's own later account explains that the melody was first written for a different gospel text during evangelistic meetings in Rutherford, New Jersey. Breck's poem arrived immediately afterward and fit the music, leading Tullar to replace his own words. The published 1899 form therefore represents an early repurposing of a newly written tune rather than music composed from the outset while looking at Breck's text.
The tune uses the clear stanza-and-refrain architecture typical of late nineteenth-century American gospel song. Its memorable melodic design supports individual testimony while the refrain creates a strong corporate response. Modern hymnals transpose the setting and sometimes alter harmony, so key, accompaniment, and later arrangements should be distinguished from Tullar's underlying public-domain melody.
Application
- Use the hymn in funerals, memorial services, services on eternal life, or worship focused on the return and final revelation of Christ.
- Pair it with 1 Corinthians 13:12 to help believers acknowledge unanswered questions without treating partial understanding as a failure of faith.
- Use 1 John 3:2 to connect the hope of seeing Christ with the Christian expectation of transformation into his likeness.
- Read Revelation 21:4 pastorally with grieving people, allowing biblical hope to coexist with honest sorrow rather than using future consolation to silence present grief.
- Teach John 14:2-3 to emphasize that Christian hope is fundamentally relational: Christ promises to receive his people so that they may be with him.
Discussion Questions
- How does 1 Corinthians 13:12 shape the hymn's contrast between present faith and future sight?
- What does 1 John 3:2 add to the idea of seeing Christ by connecting vision with transformation?
- Why is it helpful to distinguish Tullar's later autobiographical account of the melody's origin from contemporary documentation?
- How can the hymn offer comfort in grief without minimizing the reality of present sorrow?
- What changes when Christian hope is centered on communion with Christ rather than on speculation about heaven?
Teaching Tips
- Introduce the text and tune as a matched 1898 gospel-hymn collaboration first securely located in Sermons in Song No. 2 in 1899.
- Explain Tullar's jelly-dish story as his own later autobiographical recollection, preserving its historical interest without presenting every detail as independently contemporary evidence.
- Read 1 Corinthians 13:12 and 1 John 3:2 before singing so the congregation hears the biblical foundations of sight, knowledge, and transformation.
- In funeral or memorial worship, pair the hymn with Revelation 21:4 while allowing space for lament as well as assurance.
- For musicians, distinguish Tullar's underlying tune from later transpositions, harmonizations, arrangements, and recordings that may carry separate editorial or copyright histories.
Sources
-
Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology — hymn history, 1898 dating, 1 Corinthians 13:12 basis, Vineland first-singing tradition, and 1899 publication
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — text authority, Carrie Ellis Breck attribution, 1898 date, meter, translations, and hymnal circulation
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — FACE TO FACE tune authority, Grant Colfax Tullar attribution, 1898 date, meter, public-domain status, and hymnal circulation
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Sermons in Song No. 2 no. 4, 1899 first securely identified publication
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Carrie Ellis Breck biography based on Charles H. Gabriel's 1916 The Singers and Their Songs
View source ↗ -
Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology — Grant Colfax Tullar biography, evangelistic work, writing, composition, and publishing
View source ↗ -
Grant Colfax Tullar — Written Because--; and, an Autobiography, Some Stories, and Poems, Orange, New Jersey, 1937
-
Joseph A. Conwell — Religious Forces and Other Activities in the History of Vineland, New Jersey, 1916
-
Duke University Center for the Study of the Public Domain — Public Domain Day 2026 and U.S. public-domain term guidance
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, 1 Corinthians 13
View source ↗ -
Bible Gateway — World English Bible, 1 John 3:2
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, Revelation 22
View source ↗ -
Bible Gateway — World English Bible, Revelation 21:4
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, John 14
View source ↗
Sheet Music
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Help Create More Free Teaching Resources
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us research more hymns and create additional teaching materials.