Lord, I Want to Be a Christian: Meaning, History, and Theology
"Lord, I want to be a Christian in my heart"
- Category
- Hymn
- Tune
- Standard Tune
- Status
- Verified
- Rights
- Public domain
Viewed 37 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
Lord, I Want to Be a Christian is an anonymous African American spiritual praying for inward faith, love, holiness, and Christlikeness. A 1904 Fisk Jubilee-related collection securely documents the song, while the represented four-stanza text and traditional tune remain public domain.
Overview
Lord, I Want to Be a Christian is an anonymous African American spiritual shaped as a direct prayer for inward Christian formation. In the four-stanza form represented here, the singer asks for Christian identity, deeper love, greater holiness, and likeness to Jesus. The repeated emphasis on the heart makes the song less a declaration of spiritual achievement than a confession of desire and dependence on God.
Its movement is simple but theologically substantial: profession becomes character, character becomes holiness, and holiness culminates in Christlikeness. Because every petition is personal and repeatable, the spiritual works naturally as a hymn of commitment, confession, renewal, or response to preaching.
The song also carries the history of African American sacred music into congregational worship. Its anonymous origin, oral transmission, early Fisk Jubilee repertory, and later denominational arrangements all require careful distinction. The traditional text and tune are public domain, while particular modern arrangements may still be copyrighted.
Historical Background
The exact author, composer, date, and place of origin of Lord, I Want to Be a Christian are unknown. It belongs to the African American spiritual tradition, in which sacred songs circulated extensively through oral transmission before collectors fixed particular versions in print. A later theory connects the song with an eighteenth-century Virginia encounter involving an enslaved person and Presbyterian evangelist Samuel Davies, but the surviving evidence does not establish that episode as the composition event for this specific spiritual. It is best treated as a retrospective proposal rather than documented origin history.
The documentary record is earlier than some standard hymn notes suggest. Canterbury and some Hymnary commentary identify Frederick J. Work's Folk Songs of the American Negro of 1907 as the first publication, but a digitized second edition of New Jubilee Songs: As Sung by the Fisk Jubilee Singers, dated 1904 and collected and harmonized by Frederick J. Work, already prints Lord, I Want to Be a Christian on page 17. WorldCat catalogs a first edition of New Jubilee Songs published by Fisk University in 1902, although the contents of that first edition were not independently inspected here. The 1904 scan is therefore the earliest directly verified complete printed witness used for this record.
The 1904 witness has five stanzas and preserves the dialectal refrain form “in-a my heart.” It includes petitions to be a Christian, more loving, and more holy; a stanza rejecting likeness to Judas; and a final prayer to be like Jesus. Frederick J. Work's title page identifies him as collector and harmonizer, not as the documented creator of the underlying spiritual. Folk Songs of the American Negro in 1907 printed the song again; its preface credits Frederick J. Work as editor and acknowledges John W. Work Jr. and Agnes Work for collecting and assembling the repertory.
Later hymnals reshaped the wording and stanza selection. Many omit the Judas stanza and regularize “in-a my heart” to “in my heart.” The four-stanza form selected for this record is independently printed as a public-domain African American spiritual in Worship and Rejoice, 2003, hymn 457. That hymnal also identifies the tune I WANT TO BE A CHRISTIAN as a public-domain African American spiritual. This makes the represented text a later standardized traditional form rather than a verbatim transcription of the 1904 Fisk-related witness.
A separate modern setting appears in The United Methodist Hymnal, 1989, hymn 402. It credits William Farley Smith with a 1986 adaptation and arrangement and copyrights that treatment to The United Methodist Publishing House. Smith therefore should not be presented as composer of the traditional spiritual, and his arrangement is not the represented public-domain setting in this record. Similar distinctions apply to other later choral, organ, and congregational arrangements.
The represented traditional text and tune are public domain in both selected jurisdictions. In the United States, the Copyright Office states that all works published before January 1, 1931 are now public domain. In the Philippines, anonymous works are generally protected for fifty years from lawful publication unless authorship is revealed earlier; the song was in print by 1904 and no original author or composer has been established. Modern arrangements and editorial settings must still be assessed separately.
Biblical Foundations
Psalm 51:10 gives the strongest biblical parallel to the spiritual's repeated concern with the heart. The prayer for a clean heart and a renewed spirit shows that inward transformation is a gift sought from God rather than merely an exercise in self-improvement.
First Thessalonians 3:12-13 joins two petitions that the spiritual places in sequence: increasing love and hearts established in holiness. The passage helps show that Christian love and holiness are not rival ideals but mutually reinforcing dimensions of mature discipleship.
First Peter 1:15-16 grounds holiness in the character and call of God, while 1 Peter 2:21 presents Christ as an example whose steps believers are called to follow. First John 3:2-3 then points toward the hope of becoming like Christ and connects that hope with present purification.
These passages are editorial biblical foundations selected because they illuminate the song's petitions. The early printed witnesses consulted do not identify a single Scripture text as the documented inspiration for the spiritual.
Verse Explanation
The represented four-stanza text begins with the foundational desire to be genuinely Christian at the level of the heart. It is a prayer for identity to become inward allegiance rather than merely a name.
The second stanza turns from identity to love. The request for greater love implies continuing formation: Christian discipleship is not static but grows toward deeper charity.
The third stanza asks for greater holiness, moving the prayer toward conduct and conformity to God's character. The fourth gathers the earlier petitions into the desire to become like Jesus, making Christlikeness the goal toward which identity, love, and holiness point.
The early 1904 printed witness contains an additional stanza rejecting likeness to Judas and uses the refrain wording “in-a my heart.” The present four-stanza version follows the public-domain form printed in Worship and Rejoice in 2003 rather than combining that modernized form with the older Fisk-related text.
Theological Reflection
The spiritual is a compact theology of sanctification. Its grammar is aspirational: the singer does not announce that Christian maturity has been achieved but asks God for a deeper reality than outward identification. That posture fits a theology in which holiness is received as grace and pursued through continuing discipleship.
Love, holiness, and Christlikeness form the central progression. Christian identity is not allowed to remain a label; the prayer presses inward toward transformed desire and outward toward a way of life shaped by love and holiness. Christ himself becomes the final personal measure of the transformation sought.
The repeated language of the heart should not be read as private spirituality detached from action. In biblical usage the heart concerns intention, allegiance, desire, and moral direction. A changed heart therefore seeks expression in conduct, relationships, worship, and obedience.
Because this prayer comes from the African American spiritual tradition, it should also be heard within a communal history marked by slavery, racial oppression, Black Christian worship, survival, and hope. The absence of a documented individual origin prevents assigning a specific circumstance to this song, but it does not justify detaching the spiritual from the tradition that preserved and transmitted it.
Church Impact
Lord, I Want to Be a Christian has become one of the more widely transmitted African American spirituals in denominational hymnody. Hymnary currently indexes the text in roughly 195 hymnals and the tune in more than 150, demonstrating substantial publication across Protestant traditions while not proving identical performance practice in every congregation.
Its short petitions make it especially adaptable for commitment, confession, sanctification, children's worship, evangelistic response, and services focused on Christian formation. Methodist, Presbyterian, Reformed, Baptist, African Methodist Episcopal, and ecumenical hymnals all preserve versions of the song.
Its continuing use also carries a responsibility of historical memory. Worship leaders can honor the song's African American heritage by identifying it as a traditional spiritual, avoiding unproven origin stories, and distinguishing early collectors such as Frederick J. Work from unknown original creators and later arrangers such as William Farley Smith.
Musical Notes
The traditional tune is commonly called I WANT TO BE A CHRISTIAN. Hymnary identifies its source as an African American spiritual and gives the tune as public domain. Early printings connected with Frederick J. Work preserve the melody in staff notation, while Work's title page identifies him as collector and harmonizer rather than as the documented composer of the underlying tune.
Hymnological commentary describes the melody as slow, sustained, and long-phrased and notes its suitability for call-and-response performance. A leader or unison group can sing the petition while the gathered community answers with the recurring heart refrain. This performance logic fits the repetitive design of the spiritual without requiring elaborate accompaniment.
Later hymnals present different keys, harmonizations, and editorial treatments. The United Methodist Hymnal uses William Farley Smith's 1986 adaptation and arrangement, first published there in 1989, and that specific treatment is copyrighted. Such later settings should be distinguished from the anonymous traditional tune represented here.
Application
- Pray for Christian identity to become inward conviction rather than a merely external label.
- Ask God to enlarge love toward other people, especially where patience, mercy, or reconciliation are difficult.
- Treat holiness as a pattern of daily conduct grounded in God's call, not simply as a religious feeling.
- Use the life and character of Jesus as the measure for continuing discipleship.
- When teaching or singing the spiritual, name its African American heritage and distinguish the anonymous traditional song from later copyrighted arrangements.
Discussion Questions
- Why does the spiritual repeat the desire for change in the heart rather than beginning with outward behavior?
- How do the petitions for Christian identity, love, holiness, and Christlikeness describe a progression in spiritual formation?
- What does the five-stanza 1904 witness reveal about the way oral spirituals can change when transmitted through hymnals?
- Why is it important to distinguish anonymous traditional creators from collectors, harmonizers, editors, and later arrangers?
- How can a congregation honor the African American heritage of this spiritual while also receiving it as a personal prayer of discipleship?
Teaching Tips
- Introduce the song as an anonymous traditional African American spiritual; do not assign a known original author or composer.
- Explain that a 1904 second edition of New Jubilee Songs securely documents the song before the often-cited 1907 Folk Songs of the American Negro printing.
- Compare the 1904 five-stanza form with the common four-stanza form to illustrate oral transmission and hymnal editing without treating either version as a reconstruction of the other.
- Connect the petitions for love, holiness, and Christlikeness with 1 Thessalonians 3:12-13, 1 Peter 1:15-16, and 1 John 3:2-3.
- If using William Farley Smith's United Methodist setting, identify him as adapter and arranger of the traditional music and respect the separate copyright on that arrangement.
Sources
-
Digital Library of Georgia — New Jubilee Songs, 1904 second edition, Lord I Want to Be a Christian on page 17
View source ↗ -
WorldCat — New Jubilee Songs, Fisk University, 1902 catalog record
View source ↗ -
Digital Library of Georgia — Folk Songs of the American Negro, 1907, edited by Frederick J. Work
View source ↗ -
The Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology — Lord, I want to be a Christian
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Lord, I Want to Be a Christian text authority and transmission notes
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — I WANT TO BE A CHRISTIAN tune authority
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Worship and Rejoice 2003 hymn 457, selected four-stanza public-domain text and tune
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — The United Methodist Hymnal 1989 hymn 402, William Farley Smith adaptation and arrangement
View source ↗ -
U.S. Copyright Office — What is Copyright?, current public-domain cutoff guidance
View source ↗ -
Intellectual Property Office of the Philippines — Copyright Reference Book, anonymous works term
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, Psalm 51
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, 1 Thessalonians 3
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, 1 Peter 1
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, 1 Peter 2
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, 1 John 3
View source ↗
Lord, I Want to Be a Christian Lyrics and Guitar Chords
Tune
Sheet Music
Learn This Hymn
Tune: Standard Tune
Accompaniment Versions
Choose the accompaniment version that matches how many stanzas you plan to sing.
4 stanzas
Help Keep HymnInfo Free
HymnInfo provides researched hymn histories, Scripture studies, recordings, sheet music, and teaching resources without charge. If this resource has helped you, your support helps us keep improving and expanding it.
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Help Create More Free Teaching Resources
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us research more hymns and create additional teaching materials.