For All the Saints: Meaning, History, and Theology
"For all the saints who from their labors rest"
- Written
- 1864
- Category
- Hymn
- Tune
- Standard Tune
- Status
- Verified
- Rights
- Public domain
Viewed 51 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
For All the Saints is William Walsham How’s 1864 All Saints hymn, inspired explicitly by the “cloud of witnesses” in Hebrews 12:1. Ralph Vaughan Williams’s SINE NOMINE, written for The English Hymnal in 1906, became its best-known musical setting and carries the text from remembrance through perseverance to resurrection hope.
Overview
For All the Saints is a hymn of thanksgiving, perseverance, and Christian hope built around the biblical image of a “great cloud of witnesses.” William Walsham How addresses Christ in gratitude for believers who confessed him faithfully and have now entered their rest. The hymn then turns toward Christians still living, placing their struggles within the same story of faith and urging them to continue toward the promised victory of God.
Its spiritual movement is larger than remembrance alone. The saints are not praised as independent heroes; Christ is their rock, captain, light, and source of victory. The hymn holds together the church on earth and the church in glory, presenting them as one fellowship in Christ while still distinguishing present struggle from completed rest. That balance gives the text both commemorative warmth and a strong call to discipleship.
The later stanzas widen the horizon from individual remembrance to resurrection and final worship. Warfare imagery gives way to evening, rest, dawn, the rising of the saints, and the gathering of a countless host before the triune God. This progression makes the hymn especially effective on All Saints’ Day, at funerals and memorial services, and whenever a congregation needs to connect grief with resurrection hope and present faithfulness with the promised completion of God’s kingdom.
Historical Background
William Walsham How first published For All the Saints in 1864 in Horatio Nelson’s Hymns for Saints’ Days, and Other Hymns. How was then rector of Whittington in Shropshire. The first printing contained eleven three-line stanzas with an Alleluia refrain, began “For all Thy saints,” and carried the heading “Saints’-Day Hymn. A cloud of witnesses. — Heb. 12:1.” No music was printed with that first edition, so the text and the tune now most closely associated with it belong to different stages of the hymn’s history.
How revised the hymn more than once. In A Supplement to Psalms & Hymns (1867), which he co-edited with Thomas Baker Morrell, he changed the opening to “For all the saints” and adjusted other wording. Church Hymns (1871), another collection with which How was closely involved, introduced further revisions; hymnologist John Julian later treated this 1871 form as the authorized text. The original eleven stanzas included separate sections for apostles, evangelists, and martyrs. Most later hymnals omit those three, which is why an eight-stanza sequence became especially common.
Before SINE NOMINE appeared, editors tried several musical settings. The 1874 music edition of Church Hymns used an Anglican chant associated with William Hayes, and Hymns Ancient & Modern used a chant by Arthur Troyte in 1875. Joseph Barnby’s tune published in the Sarum Hymnal in 1869—later known as FOR ALL THE SAINTS, SARUM, or ST. PHILIP—also became widely associated with How’s text. In 1904 Charles Villiers Stanford supplied the ambitious tune ENGELBERG for a revised edition of Hymns Ancient & Modern.
Ralph Vaughan Williams transformed the hymn’s musical reception while serving as musical editor of The English Hymnal. For the 1906 book he composed SINE NOMINE specifically for How’s text. The original score printed the composer simply as “Anon.” and used eight stanzas of the 1871 text, omitting the apostle, evangelist, and martyr stanzas. Vaughan Williams provided contrasting unison and harmonized treatment for different stanzas, with a firm organ part and recurring Alleluia phrases that give the long procession a strong sense of momentum.
The 1906 rhythmic setting was not completely fixed for later use. Vaughan Williams revised the tune in Songs of Praise in 1925, and a revised form also appeared in the 1933 English Hymnal. Even so, SINE NOMINE became the dominant modern pairing. Hymnary indexes How’s text in more than six hundred hymnals and the tune itself in nearly three hundred, documenting broad transmission through Anglican, Methodist, Lutheran, Presbyterian, Reformed, Baptist, Roman Catholic, and ecumenical collections. Such bibliographic reach demonstrates circulation, not identical frequency of singing in every tradition.
For the jurisdictions screened here, both the selected 1906 eight-stanza text and Vaughan Williams’s 1906 tune are public domain as of 2026. How died in 1897 and Vaughan Williams in 1958; Philippine law generally protects identified literary and musical works for life plus fifty years. In the United States, the Copyright Office states that works published before January 1, 1931 are in the public domain. Modern arrangements, descants, edited harmonizations, recordings, and altered texts can carry separate rights and should not be assumed to share the status of the historical words and tune.
Biblical Foundations
Hebrews 12:1–2 is not merely an editorial association: the 1864 first printing explicitly headed the hymn with Hebrews 12:1 and the phrase “a cloud of witnesses.” How’s procession therefore begins from a documented biblical frame. The passage looks back to faithful witnesses while directing the living church to lay aside sin, persevere in its race, and keep its attention on Jesus. That movement closely matches the hymn’s transition from gratitude for the departed to exhortation for believers who are still struggling.
Revelation 14:13 supplies another unusually direct echo: the blessed dead “rest from their labors.” The hymn’s opening rest therefore belongs to the New Testament hope of those who die in the Lord rather than to a vague idea of peaceful memory. Second Timothy 4:7–8 illuminates the military and athletic language of perseverance, completed course, faithful struggle, and crown.
The closing vision is strongly resonant with Revelation 7:9–12, where a countless multitude from every nation stands before God and the Lamb in worship. First Corinthians 15:54–57 completes the resurrection logic of the hymn: death is not the final word, because victory is given through Jesus Christ. Together these passages explain why the text can move through death, struggle, rest, dawn, resurrection, and universal praise without treating any single stage as the whole Christian hope.
Verse Explanation
The selected 1906 English Hymnal version contains eight stanzas. The first two look back with gratitude on believers who have completed their earthly work and confess that Christ was their sustaining strength and light. The emphasis falls first on Christ’s faithfulness and on the saints’ confession of him.
The third stanza turns toward the living church and asks for courageous perseverance. The fourth becomes the theological center of the hymn, holding together believers who still struggle and those already in glory as one fellowship belonging to Christ. The fifth then returns to the experience of prolonged conflict and to the encouragement that comes from hearing, as it were, the distant song of victory.
The sixth stanza changes the imagery from battle to evening and rest, allowing a quieter moment before the final movement. The seventh breaks that stillness with resurrection dawn and the triumph of the saints under the King of glory. The eighth expands the scene to a worldwide multitude entering praise of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
This eight-stanza form should not be mistaken for How’s complete 1864 original, which had eleven stanzas. The 1906 editors omitted the separate stanzas for apostles, evangelists, and martyrs, following a pattern that became common in later hymnals.
Theological Reflection
The hymn’s central doctrine is the communion of saints: the church is one body in Christ even though some believers still struggle in earthly discipleship while others have completed their course. How does not erase the difference between those conditions. The living are still called to endurance; the departed are described as resting in Christ. Their unity comes from belonging to the same Lord, not from denying the reality of death.
A second theme is Christ-centered sainthood. The hymn is addressed to Jesus, and its remembered believers are defined by faith in him. Their courage is not self-generated heroism: Christ is portrayed as strength, protection, command, and light. This keeps remembrance from becoming mere admiration of exemplary people and places sanctity within the grace and lordship of Christ.
The hymn also presents perseverance as a communal vocation. The “cloud of witnesses” does not invite passive nostalgia; it encourages present believers to continue the race. The struggle imagery is spiritual and moral, calling Christians to faithfulness amid sin, suffering, and opposition. It should therefore be read alongside New Testament language about endurance rather than as a celebration of earthly violence.
Finally, the hymn is thoroughly eschatological. Rest in paradise is not its last image. A more glorious day breaks, the saints rise, and the worldwide company gathers in praise of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Christian hope is thus not reduced to the survival of memory or even to disembodied repose; it points toward resurrection, renewed creation, and the final worshiping community gathered by God.
Church Impact
For All the Saints has had exceptionally broad hymnal circulation. Hymnary indexes How’s text in more than six hundred hymnals, while SINE NOMINE appears in nearly three hundred. The text crossed denominational boundaries long before Vaughan Williams’s tune became dominant, and later collections carried the hymn through Anglican, Methodist, Lutheran, Presbyterian, Reformed, Baptist, Roman Catholic, Mennonite, and ecumenical worship traditions.
Its strongest liturgical association is All Saints’ Day, where the hymn’s movement from remembrance to perseverance and final resurrection directly serves the feast’s theology. It has also become an important funeral and memorial hymn because it names death honestly while refusing to end with death. The closing worldwide procession gives congregations language for imagining the church not merely as a local institution but as a people gathered across generations and nations.
The pairing with SINE NOMINE strengthened that reception by giving the text a musical architecture capable of sustaining many stanzas in procession. Even so, the hymn’s history is not reducible to one tune or one eight-stanza selection. Different hymnals continue to omit, restore, modernize, or rearrange stanzas, so its continuing use also illustrates the editorial life of a hymn as it moves through changing worship traditions.
Musical Notes
SINE NOMINE was composed by Ralph Vaughan Williams specifically for For All the Saints and first appeared with the text in The English Hymnal in 1906. The tune is in 10.10.10.4 meter with the Alleluia refrain; the original 1906 score is printed in G major and marks a moderate tempo. The Latin title means “without name.” Although later writers have connected that title symbolically with unnamed saints, the safer historical point is simply that Vaughan Williams used the traditional Latin designation for an untitled or unnamed setting.
The original arrangement is more carefully varied than a simple repeated four-part hymn tune. Stanzas 1, 2, 3, 7, and 8 are marked for voices in unison, while stanzas 4, 5, and 6 receive harmonized treatment; the score notes that stanzas 4 and 6 may be sung by the choir alone. A strongly moving bass line and recurring Alleluia gesture give the music processional energy without requiring a fast tempo.
Vaughan Williams later revised aspects of the rhythmic setting, and modern hymnals may print the tune in different keys or harmonizations. Alternative historical tunes include Barnby’s SARUM or ST. PHILIP and Stanford’s ENGELBERG. Worship leaders should therefore distinguish the underlying public-domain tune from any later copyrighted descant, orchestration, organ arrangement, or editorial harmonization.
Application
- Give thanks for particular Christians whose faith has helped form your own, while directing final praise to Christ rather than idealizing them.
- When grief is fresh, use the hymn’s movement from rest to resurrection to hold sorrow and Christian hope together without rushing either one.
- Read Hebrews 12:1–2 as a call to continue the race of faith, not merely as a description of believers who have already died.
- Let the witness of earlier generations encourage concrete faithfulness in prayer, service, courage, and resistance to sin.
- Use the worldwide vision of Revelation 7 to remember that the communion of saints crosses national, ethnic, linguistic, and historical boundaries.
- At funerals and memorials, distinguish Christian resurrection hope from vague claims that death itself is harmless or unreal.
Discussion Questions
- Why did How place Hebrews 12:1 at the head of the original hymn, and how does that passage shape the whole text?
- How does the hymn keep Christ, rather than the saints themselves, at the center of thanksgiving?
- What is meant by the communion of saints, and how does the hymn distinguish the church on earth from the church at rest?
- Why does the hymn move from battle imagery to evening, dawn, resurrection, and worldwide worship?
- How does knowing that the original 1864 text had eleven stanzas change the way we understand the common eight-stanza version?
- What can present-day believers learn from earlier Christians without idealizing the past or ignoring their limitations?
Teaching Tips
- Begin with Hebrews 12:1–2 and explain that the first 1864 printing explicitly used the “cloud of witnesses” heading.
- Show learners the difference between How’s eleven-stanza original and the eight-stanza selection used in The English Hymnal of 1906.
- Trace the tune history from earlier chants and Barnby’s setting through Stanford’s ENGELBERG to Vaughan Williams’s SINE NOMINE.
- When teaching SINE NOMINE, point out the original alternation between unison and harmonized stanzas instead of treating every stanza identically.
- Use Revelation 14:13 and Revelation 7:9–12 to connect the hymn’s images of rest and the countless host directly with Scripture.
- In funeral use, allow space for grief while explaining that the hymn’s final Christian claim is resurrection and the victory of Christ, not the denial of loss.
Sources
-
Hymnology Archive — For all the saints: 1864 publication, revisions, tune history, and documentary sources
View source ↗ -
Hymnology Archive — William Walsham How biographical profile and primary-source references
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — For all the Saints text authority, original eleven-stanza history, Scripture, and hymnal circulation
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — SINE NOMINE tune authority, 1906 composition, meter, and public-domain status
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — The English Hymnal 1906, hymn 641
View source ↗ -
Wikisource — The English Hymnal 1906, hymn 641 score page 826, lyric witness stanzas 1-3 and 7-8
View source ↗ -
Wikisource — The English Hymnal 1906, hymn 641 score page 827, lyric witness continuation
View source ↗ -
Wikimedia scan — The English Hymnal 1906, hymn 641 score page 828, lyric witness stanzas 4-6
View source ↗ -
Ralph Vaughan Williams Society — Short biography of Ralph Vaughan Williams
View source ↗ -
Vaughan Williams Foundation — Published works, including SINE NOMINE in The English Hymnal 1906
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, Hebrews 12
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, Revelation 14
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, 2 Timothy 4
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, Revelation 7
View source ↗ -
eBible.org — World English Bible Classic, 1 Corinthians 15
View source ↗ -
U.S. Copyright Office — What Is Copyright, including current public-domain cutoff for published U.S. works
View source ↗ -
LawPhil — Republic Act No. 8293, Sections 213 and 214 on Philippine copyright terms
View source ↗
For All the Saints Lyrics and Guitar Chords
Tune
Sheet Music
Learn This Hymn
Tune: Standard Tune
Accompaniment Versions
Choose the accompaniment version that matches how many stanzas you plan to sing.
6 stanzas
Help Keep HymnInfo Free
HymnInfo provides researched hymn histories, Scripture studies, recordings, sheet music, and teaching resources without charge. If this resource has helped you, your support helps us keep improving and expanding it.
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Help Create More Free Teaching Resources
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us research more hymns and create additional teaching materials.