In Christ There Is No East or West Meaning, History, and Theology
"In Christ there is no east or west"
- Written
- 1908
- Category
- Hymn
- Tune
- Standard Tune
- Status
- Published
Viewed 128 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
In Christ There Is No East or West began as John Oxenham's 1908 text for a London Missionary Society pageant and became a hymn of Christian unity and reconciliation. In North America it is often sung to MCKEE, an African American spiritual melody adapted and harmonized by Harry T. Burleigh in 1939.
Overview
In Christ There Is No East or West is a hymn of Christian unity grounded in the conviction that belonging to Christ creates a fellowship deeper than geography, ethnicity, nationality, class, or other social boundaries. Its enduring theological center is not the disappearance of human difference but the creation of a reconciled people whose primary identity and communion are found in Christ.
That message makes the hymn both consoling and demanding. Christian unity is received as a gift through Christ, yet the church is called to make that unity visible in fellowship, worship, service, and resistance to prejudice. The hymn therefore belongs naturally in services concerned with reconciliation, ecumenism, racial justice, global mission, World Communion, and the nature of the church.
Its history also gives the hymn unusual musical and cultural depth. An English text written for an early twentieth-century missionary pageant later became closely associated in North America with MCKEE, an African American spiritual melody adapted by Harry T. Burleigh. That pairing can enrich the hymn's witness when worshipers understand both traditions rather than treating either one as culturally anonymous.
Historical Background
In Christ There Is No East or West began not as a conventional hymnal commission but as part of a large missionary spectacle in London. In 1908 the London Missionary Society staged The Orient in London, an exhibition intended to present its worldwide mission work to the British public. The Pageant of Darkness and Light formed a major part of the event. Library and archival catalogs identify John Oxenham and Hugh Moss with the pageant's design, Oxenham with the words, and Scottish composer Hamish MacCunn with the music. Oxenham's concluding poem carried the title No East or West and expressed a vision of Christian fellowship across the geographic divisions represented in the pageant.
William Arthur Dunkerley, writing as John Oxenham, later separated the poem from its theatrical setting. In 1913 he included No East or West in Bees in Amber: A Little Book of Thoughtful Verse. The volume became a notable publishing success after he issued it himself. Hymnologist J. R. Watson has observed that the poem's opening idea reverses the famous East-West contrast associated with Rudyard Kipling: for Oxenham, the decisive reality is not permanent separation but communion in Christ.
The poem moved into congregational hymnody during the following decades. It appeared in American hymn collections by the mid-1920s and was included in the enlarged Songs of Praise in Britain in 1931. Its common meter allowed it to travel easily among established tunes. For many years ST. PETER, composed by Alexander Robert Reinagle in 1836, was one of its principal settings and remains common in several traditions.
The most historically distinctive later pairing came through Harry T. Burleigh. In 1939 Burleigh adapted and harmonized an African American spiritual melody associated with I Know the Angels Done Changed My Name and named the result MCKEE for Elmer M. McKee, rector of St. George's Episcopal Church in New York, where Burleigh served as baritone soloist for decades. The new setting brought Oxenham's British missionary-era text into direct musical conversation with African American sacred tradition. MCKEE subsequently became a major North American tune for the hymn and is now used across numerous denominational hymnals.
The text itself also changed. Oxenham's original third stanza used explicitly male kinship language typical of its period. During preparation of The United Methodist Hymnal, Laurence Hull Stookey was asked to make the language inclusive. He later explained that instead of merely adjusting individual words, he wrote a replacement stanza grounded in Galatians 3:28. Hymnary dates his contribution to 1987, and the 1989 hymnal identifies stanza three as copyrighted by The United Methodist Publishing House.
This copyright distinction matters for the present record. Oxenham's original 1908 text and the traditional MCKEE melody with Burleigh's 1939 adaptation are identified as public domain in current hymnological resources, but the Stookey replacement stanza represented among the contributors is not. The hymn's reception has therefore produced both public-domain and copyrighted forms, and worship leaders must check the exact text and arrangement they use.
Biblical Foundations
Galatians 3:28 provides the hymn's most direct scriptural foundation. Paul's declaration of unity in Christ does not imply that ethnic, social, or gender realities cease to exist; rather, those distinctions cannot determine access to Christ or establish superior standing within the people of God. Christian identity is re-centered in union with Christ.
Ephesians 2:14-18 gives this unity a strongly christological and reconciling foundation. Christ is himself the peace of the church, breaking hostility and creating one reconciled body through the cross. Unity is therefore more than friendliness between groups: it belongs to the saving work of Christ and to shared access to the Father in one Spirit.
Colossians 3:11 reinforces the same ecclesial vision by placing diverse peoples within a renewed humanity in which Christ is all and in all. John 17:20-23 adds Jesus' prayer that the unity of believers become a visible witness to the world. Division is thus not merely an internal church problem; it can obscure the church's testimony to Christ.
Revelation 7:9-10 gives the hymn an eschatological horizon. The final vision is not cultural sameness but a worshiping multitude drawn from every nation, tribe, people, and language. Christian unity reaches its fullness not by erasing peoples but by gathering them before God and the Lamb.
Verse Explanation
The hymn is best understood through several connected theological themes: union with Christ, reconciliation across human divisions, shared Christian fellowship, service, and the worldwide identity of the church. Its scriptural center is Galatians 3:28, strengthened by Ephesians 2's teaching that Christ creates one reconciled body and Revelation 7's vision of worshipers gathered from every people and language.
Its historical revisions also illuminate its theology. The original language reflected early twentieth-century conventions, while later editors sought wording that would express the hymn's claim to unity without retaining gender-exclusive language. Laurence Hull Stookey's replacement stanza in The United Methodist Hymnal was written from Galatians 3:28 rather than as a simple word-for-word modernization.
Theological Reflection
The hymn's central doctrine is the unity of the church in Christ. This unity is prior to human achievement: Christians do not create the body of Christ by learning to agree with one another. They are reconciled through Christ and then called to live in ways consistent with that gift. Ecumenism, racial reconciliation, and cross-cultural fellowship are therefore responses to the gospel rather than optional social additions to it.
At the same time, unity should not be confused with uniformity. Revelation's vision retains nations, tribes, peoples, and languages even in worship before the Lamb. The church's calling is not to flatten cultural distinction but to refuse to turn difference into domination, exclusion, contempt, or unequal belonging.
The hymn also carries a missional challenge. Its origin in a missionary pageant reflects the global imagination of early twentieth-century Protestant mission, including assumptions of its historical period that deserve critical examination. Yet its most durable claim moves beyond cultural superiority: fellowship in Christ places Christians from different peoples within one communion and requires mutual recognition rather than a one-directional relationship between supposed givers and receivers.
When sung to MCKEE, the hymn adds another layer of historical meaning. An English missionary text is carried by music rooted in African American spiritual tradition and shaped for hymnody by a Black American composer-arranger. That history can embody the hymn's theology only when the source community and Burleigh's contribution are named rather than absorbed anonymously into a generic musical tradition.
Church Impact
The hymn moved from a London Missionary Society pageant into a broad ecumenical repertoire. Hymnary documents it in hundreds of hymnals across Anglican, Methodist, Presbyterian, Lutheran, Baptist, Reformed, Mennonite, Catholic, African American, evangelical, and other traditions. Its subjects commonly include Christian unity, reconciliation, mission, fellowship, race and culture, ecumenism, and the universal church.
Its liturgical use has also changed with its reception. What began within the missionary movement is now frequently sung for World Communion, ecumenical gatherings, services of reconciliation, racial-justice observances, mission events, and occasions emphasizing the global body of Christ. C. Michael Hawn notes that its center of gravity has shifted from early twentieth-century world mission toward Christian unity in the contemporary church.
The adoption of MCKEE has been especially important in North America. The setting appears in The Hymnal 1982, The United Methodist Hymnal, Evangelical Lutheran Worship, Lift Every Voice and Sing II, African American Heritage Hymnal, Presbyterian collections, Catholic worship books, and other resources. Its presence helped bring Burleigh's treatment of African American spiritual melody into mainstream denominational hymnody.
The hymn remains useful because its confession is still unfinished in practice. Churches continue to confront racial, national, denominational, economic, and cultural divisions. Singing the hymn responsibly therefore requires more than celebrating an ideal; it invites communities to test their actual patterns of belonging, leadership, fellowship, mission, and reconciliation against the unity they confess in Christ.
Musical Notes
The text is in common meter, 8.6.8.6, which explains its association with several tunes. ST. PETER by Alexander Robert Reinagle, composed in 1836, became an important early setting and remains common in British and North American hymnals. Other traditions use KILMARNOCK, LAND OF REST, and additional common-meter melodies.
MCKEE is now one of the hymn's most significant North American settings. Harry T. Burleigh adapted and harmonized it in 1939 from an African American spiritual melody associated with I Know the Angels Done Changed My Name. Hymnary identifies the tune as common meter and public domain and records it in keys including C major, B-flat major, and A minor depending on the hymnal.
Burleigh's setting should be described as an adaptation and harmonization rather than an original composition of the underlying melody. The tune's title honors Elmer M. McKee of St. George's Episcopal Church in New York. Burleigh's long service at St. George's and his work arranging spirituals placed him at a crucial intersection of African American sacred tradition, concert music, and American church music.
MCKEE benefits from a natural, unforced pulse and clear phrasing. Worship leaders should resist treating the spiritual source as merely decorative; understanding its history can deepen the hymn's themes of dignity, fellowship, and reconciliation. Modern descants, accompaniments, and reharmonizations should be checked separately for copyright.
Application
- Examine church practices that unintentionally make one ethnicity, nationality, class, language, or cultural style appear more fully Christian than others.
- Build relationships across congregational and cultural boundaries through shared worship, meals, service, study, and sustained partnership rather than occasional symbolic events alone.
- When conflict arises, use Ephesians 2:14-18 to ask how the reconciling work of Christ should reshape hostility, power, and belonging within the church.
- Practice global Christian awareness by learning from churches outside your own nation and tradition, not only by viewing them as recipients of mission or assistance.
- When using MCKEE, teach its African American spiritual background and Harry T. Burleigh's role so that the music's history contributes to the congregation's understanding of reconciliation and cultural dignity.
- Check the exact hymnal version before reproducing the text, because Oxenham's original is public domain while Laurence Hull Stookey's replacement stanza remains copyrighted.
Discussion Questions
- How does Galatians 3:28 affirm unity in Christ without requiring the erasure of cultural or social difference?
- What does Ephesians 2:14-18 suggest about the relationship between reconciliation and the cross of Christ?
- How should the hymn's origin in an early twentieth-century British missionary exhibition shape the way we interpret its global vision today?
- What is gained when MCKEE's African American spiritual history and Harry T. Burleigh's contribution are taught alongside the hymn?
- Where do patterns of race, nationality, class, language, or denomination still limit full fellowship within the church?
- Why did Laurence Hull Stookey choose to write a new stanza from Galatians 3:28 rather than merely modernize Oxenham's older wording?
Teaching Tips
- Present the history in layers: Oxenham's 1908 missionary-pageant text, its 1913 publication as No East or West in Bees in Amber, its movement into hymnals, and Burleigh's 1939 MCKEE setting.
- Explain that John Oxenham was the pen name of William Arthur Dunkerley and that the pageant was part of the London Missionary Society exhibition The Orient in London.
- Use Galatians 3:28, Ephesians 2:14-18, John 17:20-23, and Revelation 7:9-10 to distinguish Christian unity from cultural uniformity.
- When singing MCKEE, identify it as an African American spiritual melody adapted and harmonized by Harry T. Burleigh rather than attributing the underlying tune to him as original composer.
- If using The United Methodist Hymnal version, explain that Laurence Hull Stookey supplied a modern replacement stanza and that this stanza remains copyrighted even though Oxenham's original text is public domain.
Sources
-
The London Missionary Society, The Pageant of Darkness and Light, 1908, words by John Oxenham, music by Hamish MacCunn, designed by John Oxenham and Hugh Moss
-
HathiTrust catalog record for The Pageant of Darkness and Light
-
John Oxenham, Bees in Amber: A Little Book of Thoughtful Verse, 1913, poem titled No East or West
-
Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology, entry for In Christ there is no east or west
-
C. Michael Hawn, Discipleship Ministries, History of Hymns: In Christ There Is No East or West, 2013
-
Hymnary.org, text authority page for In Christ There Is No East or West
-
Hymnary.org, tune authority page for MCKEE
-
The United Methodist Hymnal, 1989, hymn 548, including Laurence Hull Stookey's copyrighted third stanza and MCKEE
-
United Methodist News Service, Remembering professor who shaped worship, 2016, biography of Laurence Hull Stookey
-
Library of Congress, Harry Thacker Burleigh: A Guide to Resources
-
Library of Congress Historic American Buildings Survey, St. George's Episcopal Church, New York, historical documentation on Harry T. Burleigh
-
World English Bible Classic, public domain text from eBible.org
Lyrics
Lyrics Not Displayed
This hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. To respect copyright, the full lyrics are not displayed here. HymnInfo still provides historical, biblical, and theological study notes where available.
Tune
Sheet Music
Music Sheet Not Displayed
This hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. To respect copyright, the full music sheet is not displayed here. Please use a licensed hymnal, authorized publisher, or approved sheet-music provider.
Learn This Hymn
Tune: Standard Tune
Accompaniment Versions
Choose the accompaniment version that matches how many stanzas you plan to sing.
4 stanzas
Help Keep HymnInfo Free
HymnInfo provides researched hymn histories, Scripture studies, recordings, sheet music, and teaching resources without charge. If this resource has helped you, your support helps us keep improving and expanding it.
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Full lyrics and sheet music are not displayed because this hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. Teaching resources prepared for study and discussion may still be available below.
Help Create More Free Teaching Resources
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us research more hymns and create additional teaching materials.