Nothing Between: Meaning, History, and Theology
"Nothing between my soul and my Savior"
- Written
- 1905
- Category
- Hymn
- Status
- Published
- Rights
- Public domain
Viewed 79 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
“Nothing Between” is a 1905 gospel hymn for which Charles Albert Tindley wrote both words and music, with F. A. Clark as the early arranger. It calls Christians to remove rival loyalties and pursue undivided fellowship with Christ.
Overview
“Nothing Between” is a gospel hymn of consecration. Its central concern is not that Christ has withdrawn from the believer, but that competing loves, ordinary habits, social ambition, or fear may obstruct faithful fellowship with him. The song therefore turns spiritual self-examination into a repeated act of resolve.
The hymn moves from obvious temptation to subtler claims upon the heart. It treats discipleship as more than avoiding open wrongdoing: even an apparently innocent pursuit must be judged by whether it weakens loyalty to Christ. The final movement adds hardship and opposition, making perseverance—not comfort—the test of devotion.
This combination of confession, watchfulness, and confidence makes the hymn useful for services of commitment, holiness, renewal, prayer, and personal testimony. Its message is demanding without being merely anxious, because the singer’s renunciation is grounded in belonging to the Savior and seeking unhindered communion with him.
Historical Background
Charles Albert Tindley wrote “Nothing Between” while serving in the Methodist Episcopal ministry during the formative years of African American gospel hymnody. Born in Maryland in 1851, Tindley pursued education largely through his own effort, entered the Delaware Conference, and in 1902 returned as pastor to the Philadelphia congregation where he had once worked as a janitor. That congregation expanded greatly under his leadership and was later known as Tindley Temple. His hymns emerged from a ministry in which preaching, testimony, social responsibility, and congregational song were closely joined.
The strongest dating evidence is the song’s own copyright notice. Early printed copies credit the words and music to C. A. Tindley, the arrangement to F. A. Clark, and carry a 1905 copyright. Hymnological databases consequently date both text and tune to 1905. The hymn was included as number 8 in the enlarged “Soul Echoes No. 2” of 1909, and a 1924 printing in “The Baptist Standard Hymnal” preserves the same division of responsibility: Tindley wrote both text and music, while Clark arranged the score.
A later account published by United Methodist Discipleship Ministries places the hymn around 1906, when Tindley’s growing congregation was negotiating for a larger Philadelphia property. That account interprets the song’s call to sacrifice in light of the demands surrounding the church’s expansion. Because the surviving copyright notice is dated 1905, it is safest to retain 1905 as the record’s date while treating the more specific 1906 setting as a later historical interpretation rather than a precisely documented composition occasion. No contemporary diary or manuscript confirming a dramatic inspiration story has been located in the sources consulted.
The hymn’s form is characteristic of the gospel song: four stanzas develop a practical spiritual argument, and a recurring refrain gathers the argument into a memorable congregational declaration. The text progresses from renouncing worldly attraction to examining apparently harmless habits, status, personal relationships, suffering, and sustained prayer. Its realism is pastoral. Tindley does not limit temptation to obvious vice; he asks worshipers to examine anything capable of dividing their allegiance.
Its continued transmission can be traced through African American Baptist and Methodist collections and through later evangelical, Episcopal, Seventh-day Adventist, and ecumenical hymnals. Hymnary indexes the text in about 150 hymnals, evidence of broad print circulation rather than proof of uniform congregational frequency. Modern hymnals sometimes present later arrangements, but the historical core remains Tindley’s text and tune with Clark’s early arrangement. Both the 1905 work and that early arrangement are now in the public domain.
Biblical Foundations
Hebrews 12:1 provides the hymn’s clearest biblical pattern: believers are to lay aside both sin and every other weight that impedes faithful perseverance. That distinction helps explain why the song examines not only sinful desire but also ordinary habits and attachments that may become spiritual obstacles.
Jesus’ warning in Matthew 6:24 gives the theme its covenantal sharpness. Divided mastery is impossible; loyalty to God cannot simply occupy one compartment alongside a rival controlling devotion. First John 2:15–17 similarly exposes worldly desire and pride as transient, contrasting them with obedience to God’s enduring will.
James 4:8 connects nearness to God with cleansed conduct and an undivided heart. Romans 8:38–39 adds an important theological balance: created powers cannot sever believers from God’s love in Christ. The hymn is therefore best heard not as fear that God’s covenant love is fragile, but as a prayerful commitment to remove self-chosen hindrances and live responsively within that secure love.
Verse Explanation
The first stanza states the governing commitment: the believer rejects the world’s deceptive claims in order to belong wholly to Christ. The focus is a clear relationship with the Savior rather than spiritual achievement for its own sake.
The second stanza deepens the examination. The danger is no longer only evident wrongdoing but familiar patterns that may appear innocent while gradually gaining control of the heart. The hymn therefore asks worshipers to evaluate habits by their spiritual effect.
The third stanza turns to identity and social attachment. Status, self-interest, and even valued human relationships must not become ultimate loyalties. The emphasis is costly resolve, recognizing that faithfulness may bring loss or pressure.
The final stanza places the commitment under trial. Opposition and suffering require watchfulness, prayer, self-denial, and perseverance. The recurring refrain gathers each stage into a communal pledge to protect unhindered devotion to Christ.
Theological Reflection
The hymn belongs to the theology of sanctification. It assumes that communion with Christ should reshape desires, habits, relationships, ambitions, and responses to suffering. Holiness is presented not as withdrawal from ordinary life but as an undivided ordering of life toward the Savior.
Its repeated self-examination also reflects the Methodist concern for perfect love or Christian perfection. In that tradition, perfection does not mean freedom from human limitation; it means mature love of God and neighbor, with rival loyalties continually brought under grace. The hymn’s language of resolve is therefore ethical and relational, not a claim of sinless self-sufficiency.
The song must also be held together with the gospel’s assurance. Christian discipline does not create Christ’s saving love or earn divine favor. Rather, renunciation, prayer, and perseverance are responses to grace. Read this way, the hymn joins serious discipleship to confidence in Christ: grace establishes the relationship, and sanctification seeks integrity within it.
Church Impact
“Nothing Between” entered print during the early development of African American gospel hymnody and circulated in collections shaped by Black Methodist and Baptist worship. Its inclusion in the National Baptist Convention’s 1924 “Baptist Standard Hymnal” is an early documented example of transmission beyond Tindley’s own songbooks.
The hymn later appeared in major denominational and evangelical collections, including “The United Methodist Hymnal,” “Lift Every Voice and Sing II,” the “Seventh-day Adventist Hymnal,” African Methodist Episcopal hymnals, and Baptist hymnals. Hymnary’s catalog of roughly 150 instances demonstrates substantial print circulation across traditions, although catalog presence alone cannot establish how frequently every congregation sang it.
Its durable usefulness comes from the way it combines personal testimony with communal formation. Churches can sing it as a call to consecration, but its historical setting also places that call within Tindley’s wider ministry of perseverance, institution-building, and African American Christian witness. Later arrangements have allowed the song to enter varied musical settings while retaining its concise demand for undivided discipleship.
Musical Notes
The historical tune is generally identified as NOTHING BETWEEN, also indexed by its opening text. Early printed evidence credits Charles Albert Tindley with both words and music and F. A. Clark with the arrangement. Clark should therefore be identified as arranger, not as the original composer.
Hymnal sources describe the meter variously as 10.9.10.9 or 10.9.11.9 with refrain, reflecting differences in syllable counting and textual variants. The stanza-and-refrain form is central to the music’s function: each stanza names a new test of discipleship, while the refrain returns the congregation to the same governing commitment. The repeated structure suits congregational singing, testimony, and invitational or consecration settings.
Later hymnals preserve Tindley’s tune in several arrangements. These include settings associated with Don Peterman, J. Edward Hoy, and Wayne Hooper. Such names indicate later arranging or editorial work and should not displace Tindley’s authorship of the original melody or Clark’s role in the early published arrangement. Some later arrangements remain separately copyrighted even though the original text, tune, and Clark arrangement are public domain.
Application
- Name one habit, ambition, possession, or relationship that currently receives loyalty belonging to Christ.
- Distinguish between something morally permissible and something spiritually helpful; not every harmless practice deserves unlimited place in life.
- Use confession and prayer to address divided motives without confusing honest repentance with despair.
- When hardship tests commitment, seek the support of Scripture, worship, and accountable Christian community rather than relying on determination alone.
- Rest spiritual discipline in God’s secure love in Christ, so that consecration becomes a response to grace rather than an attempt to earn it.
Discussion Questions
- How does the hymn distinguish obvious sin from habits or attachments that merely appear harmless?
- Why is divided loyalty a more precise description of the hymn’s concern than a general fear of losing salvation?
- How do Romans 8:38–39 and the hymn’s call to remove hindrances interpret one another?
- What does the hymn gain when read in the context of Tindley’s pastoral ministry and African American gospel hymnody?
- How can a congregation practice costly consecration without turning spiritual discipline into self-reliance?
Teaching Tips
- Begin by distinguishing Tindley’s roles as text writer and tune composer from F. A. Clark’s role as arranger.
- Compare the documented 1905 copyright with the later account that places the hymn around 1906, modeling careful treatment of historical uncertainty.
- Use Hebrews 12:1 to discuss the difference between sin and a legitimate activity that has become a hindrance.
- Pair the hymn’s demanding self-examination with Romans 8:38–39 so that assurance and sanctification remain together.
- Invite learners to identify how stanza, refrain, repetition, and congregational singing reinforce the hymn’s spiritual argument without quoting the full text.
Sources
-
Internet Archive — A. M. Townsend, ed., The Baptist Standard Hymnal, 1924, no. 319, early score crediting words and music to C. A. Tindley and arrangement to F. A. Clark
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Nothing Between text authority, date, meter, public-domain status, and hymnal instances
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — NOTHING BETWEEN tune authority, composer and later arrangement data
View source ↗ -
United Methodist Discipleship Ministries — C. Michael Hawn, History of Hymns: Nothing Between
View source ↗ -
The Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology — Nothing between my soul and the Savior
View source ↗ -
The Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology — Charles Albert Tindley
View source ↗ -
Hymnology Archive — Charles Albert Tindley biography, bibliography, and archival references
View source ↗ -
OhioLINK Electronic Theses and Dissertations Center — D. J. Young, The Ties That Bind, discussion and bibliography of Tindley’s songs and Soul Echoes
View source ↗ -
Bible Gateway — Hebrews 12:1, World English Bible
View source ↗ -
Bible Gateway — Matthew 6:24, World English Bible
View source ↗ -
Bible Gateway — 1 John 2:15–17, World English Bible
View source ↗ -
Bible Gateway — Romans 8:38–39, World English Bible
View source ↗ -
Bible Gateway — James 4:8, World English Bible
View source ↗
Sheet Music
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Help Create More Free Teaching Resources
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us research more hymns and create additional teaching materials.