Our Earth We Now Lament to See: Meaning, History, and Theology
"Our earth we now lament to see"
- Written
- 1758
- Category
- Hymn
- Status
- Verified
- Rights
- Public domain
Viewed 13 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
Our Earth We Now Lament to See is Charles Wesley’s 1758 prayer for peace, first published as “Hymn II. For Peace” in Hymns of Intercession for All Mankind. Its four stanzas move from a stark lament over war toward reconciliation, inward holiness, and the peaceful reign of God.
Overview
Our Earth We Now Lament to See is Charles Wesley’s corporate prayer for peace in a world disfigured by war. The hymn does not romanticize conflict: its opening stanzas describe violence as a field of blood and deliberately borrow biblical images associated with destruction. Yet the text is not content merely to condemn armies or governments. It turns toward the deeper violence of the human heart and asks God to replace murderous hostility with kindness, reconciliation, and love.
The hymn’s movement is therefore from lament to intercession and from external conflict to inward renewal. Wesley addresses God as the “universal friend,” asks for estranged people to be reconciled in God, and prays that kindness will be written on the inward parts. The final stanza widens the prayer again to the nations, asking that they be constrained toward peace and learn the blessings of God’s righteous reign.
For Christian worship, the text offers unusually direct language for prayer during war, communal violence, political hostility, or strained relationships. Its hope is neither passive nor sentimental: peace is pictured as a fruit of transformed hearts, reconciled relationships, and participation in the divine kingdom of “perfect love.”
Historical Background
Charles Wesley published this text in 1758 in Hymns of Intercession for All Mankind, a Bristol collection of forty hymns devoted to public and personal intercession. In the original volume it is simply “Hymn II. For Peace.” The Duke Center for Studies in the Wesleyan Tradition identifies the first edition as Bristol: Farley, 1758, and notes a Dublin reprint by Powell in 1759. The collection ranges from prayers for all humanity and the church to petitions for rulers, soldiers, travelers, prisoners, children, enemies, and other groups.
The historical setting matters. The collection appeared while Britain and other European powers were engaged in the Seven Years’ War, which had begun in 1756. Several hymns later in the volume address King George II, the Prince of Wales, Frederick the Great, the British nation, the fleet, and the army. “For Peace” stands near the beginning of the collection and frames warfare not as an occasion for patriotic triumph but as a manifestation of human violence that requires divine healing.
Wesley’s first two stanzas use severe biblical imagery. “Abaddon” comes from Revelation 9:11, where the name belongs to the angel of the abyss; “Tophet” was a biblical place-name associated with burning and judgment. Wesley applies these images to war itself. Human beings who destroy one another are portrayed as participating in a hellish disorder. The rhetoric then changes sharply: stanza three asks the “universal friend” to end unnatural discord, reconcile humanity in God, write kindness within, and drive the murderer from the heart.
The fourth stanza completes that movement by praying not for the destruction of hostile nations but for their redirection toward peace. The goal is God’s righteous reign, unity, and “the paradise of perfect love.” This makes the hymn an important example of Wesley’s social and intercessory theology: the cure for public violence includes inward sanctification and restored relationships.
The text continued to circulate in Methodist hymn collections on both sides of the Atlantic during the nineteenth century. Hymnary documents appearances in Methodist Episcopal, African Methodist Episcopal, Wesleyan Methodist, and other collections, and The United Methodist Hymnal of 1989 includes the four-stanza text as no. 449. Such appearances establish continued hymnal transmission, though they do not by themselves prove how frequently congregations sang it.
Biblical Foundations
Psalm 46:9 gives the hymn one of its clearest biblical horizons: God “makes wars cease to the end of the earth.” Wesley’s prayer likewise looks beyond temporary truces toward divine action capable of breaking the cycle of violence. Matthew 5:9 provides the corresponding Christian vocation: those who make peace are called children of God.
The third stanza’s request that God “write kindness on our inward parts” deliberately resembles Jeremiah 31:33, where the new covenant is described as God’s law written within the people. Wesley transforms that covenant image into a prayer for a heart so renewed by divine love that murder and hostility are displaced from within.
Ephesians 2:14–16 gives a specifically Christological foundation for the hymn’s language of reconciliation. Christ is “our peace,” overcoming hostility and reconciling divided people to God in one body through the cross. That passage helps clarify why Wesley can pray both for peace between peoples and for reconciliation “in thee.”
The reference to “Abaddon’s side” draws on Revelation 9:11. Wesley is not presenting warfare as a neutral political instrument; he uses apocalyptic imagery of destruction to expose its moral horror. The hymn’s biblical movement therefore runs from the reality of violent evil toward reconciliation, peacemaking, inward renewal, and God’s righteous reign.
Verse Explanation
Stanza 1 surveys the earth under the sign of war. Violence, wrong, and cruelty make the world appear as one extended field of blood, and the language deliberately strips warfare of glory by comparing its rage to hell.
Stanza 2 intensifies the indictment through the biblical images of Abaddon and Tophet. Human beings who destroy one another are pictured as mutilating their own common flesh and feeding a realm of destruction.
Stanza 3 is the theological turning point. Wesley invokes God as the universal friend and asks for discord to end through reconciliation in God. The deepest petition is inward: kindness must be written within, and the murderer driven from the heart.
Stanza 4 moves from transformed hearts back to the nations. The prayer is that those now rising against one another will pursue peace and discover the blessings of God’s righteous reign, culminating in unity and “the paradise of perfect love.”
Theological Reflection
The hymn treats peace as more than the absence of armed conflict. Wesley traces social violence back into the human heart. The decisive petition is not simply that armies stop fighting but that God “write kindness on our inward parts” and “chase the murderer from our hearts.” In Wesleyan terms, public peace is inseparable from sanctification: love must reshape the desires from which cruelty and hostility grow.
Reconciliation is also explicitly theological. The hymn asks God to “declare us reconciled in thee,” placing restored human fellowship within restored relationship to God. This resonates with the New Testament conviction that Christ himself is peace and that hostility is overcome through reconciliation in one body.
The closing vision is the kingdom of God as a community of righteous peace and “perfect love.” Wesley does not ask that one nation dominate another. He prays that the nations themselves will be constrained to pursue peace and discover the blessings of God’s reign. The hymn therefore joins personal holiness and social holiness: transformed hearts, reconciled communities, and peaceful public life belong to the same work of divine grace.
Church Impact
The hymn’s documented history is chiefly Methodist. Hymnary records it in a series of nineteenth-century Methodist and related collections, including Methodist Episcopal, African Methodist Episcopal, Wesleyan Methodist, and United Brethren hymnals. That transmission shows that Wesley’s prayer for peace remained available to churches well beyond its Seven Years’ War setting.
Its inclusion as no. 449 in The United Methodist Hymnal (1989), under themes that include social holiness, confession, the Kingdom of God, and world peace, brought the eighteenth-century text into a modern denominational hymnal. The hymn’s continuing significance lies in the unusual way it holds together lament over war, criticism of human violence, reconciliation, inward holiness, and a positive vision of social peace. Hymnal inclusion demonstrates continued editorial reception and availability, though it should not be taken as evidence that the hymn is frequently sung in every congregation.
Musical Notes
The 1758 source is a text collection and does not establish a unique tune for “Hymn II. For Peace.” The poem consists of four six-line stanzas in 8.8.8.8.8.8 meter, a form later hymnals can match with more than one suitable tune. Because the uploaded record does not identify a tune, no composer has been added to the structured contributor data.
Hymnary associates the text in The Cyber Hymnal with ST. CATHERINE, a later nineteenth-century tune tradition linked with Henri F. Hemy and James G. Walton. Hymnary’s tune authority lists both names, while the inspected public-domain Cyber Hymnal score labels the setting “St. Catherine (Walton)” and “Arr. by James George Walton, 1864.” This pairing is therefore later than Wesley’s 1758 text and should not be presented as its original tune.
Chord research outcome: not_found. A deliberate search for the exact title, first line, and the later ST. CATHERINE pairing located an inspectable public-domain score, but that score contains staff notation without printed chord symbols. No trustworthy source was located that explicitly supplies chord symbols aligned to this hymn’s words. No chords were inferred from the notation, and no AI harmonization has been added.
Application
- Use the hymn as an intercession during war, communal violence, political hostility, or international crisis, allowing its language to name the moral cost of violence without glorifying any side.
- Let the third stanza turn prayer inward: ask not only for other people to change, but for God to remove anger, contempt, and the impulses that make reconciliation impossible.
- Pair the hymn with Psalm 46, Jeremiah 31, Matthew 5, or Ephesians 2 to connect peace with God’s reign, inward renewal, peacemaking, and reconciliation in Christ.
- Use the final stanza to frame Christian peacemaking positively: the goal is not merely cessation of conflict but unity, righteous relationships, and a community shaped by love.
- In teaching or worship, explain the severe images of Abaddon and Tophet so that singers understand Wesley’s point: war is being exposed as a hellish distortion of human fellowship, not celebrated.
Discussion Questions
- Why does Wesley describe war with images such as a “field of blood,” Abaddon, and Tophet rather than with patriotic or heroic language?
- What changes when the hymn moves from condemning violence in the world to asking God to “chase the murderer from our hearts”?
- How does Jeremiah 31:33 illuminate the prayer that kindness be written on the inward parts?
- What does Ephesians 2:14–16 add to the hymn’s idea of being reconciled in God?
- How does the final stanza connect personal holiness, international peace, and the kingdom of God?
Teaching Tips
- Introduce the hymn as “Hymn II. For Peace” from Charles Wesley’s 1758 Hymns of Intercession for All Mankind rather than treating it as a generic later peace hymn.
- Read Revelation 9:11 before discussing “Abaddon,” and explain that Wesley uses destructive biblical imagery to condemn the horror of war.
- Pair stanza 3 with Jeremiah 31:33 and Ephesians 2:14–16 to show how inward renewal and reconciliation support the hymn’s social vision.
- Invite singers to trace the four-stanza movement: lament over war, intensified judgment on violence, inward reconciliation, and a final vision of peaceful divine rule.
- If the hymn is sung to a later tune, identify that pairing as later rather than implying that Wesley published the text with a fixed melody.
Sources
-
Duke Center for Studies in the Wesleyan Tradition — Hymns of Intercession for All Mankind, Bristol 1758; Hymn II, “For Peace,” original text and collection context
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Text authority for Our Earth We Now Lament to See; Charles Wesley, 1758, public-domain status, hymnal instances, and later ST. CATHERINE association
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — The United Methodist Hymnal 1989, no. 449; four-stanza modernized text and denominational subject indexing
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — ST. CATHERINE tune authority; Henri F. Hemy and James G. Walton attribution, meter, 1864 source, and public-domain status
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org / The Cyber Hymnal — Public-domain ST. CATHERINE score inspected for chord research; staff notation has no printed chord symbols
View source ↗ -
Dictionary of National Biography — Charles Wesley biographical and hymn-writing record
View source ↗ -
Lawphil — Republic Act No. 8293, section 213.1, Philippine copyright term of life plus fifty years
View source ↗ -
U.S. Copyright Office — Current public-domain guidance for works published before January 1, 1931
View source ↗ -
World English Bible Classic — Psalm 46
View source ↗ -
World English Bible Classic — Jeremiah 31
View source ↗ -
World English Bible Classic — Ephesians 2
View source ↗ -
World English Bible Classic — Matthew 5
View source ↗ -
World English Bible Classic — Revelation 9
View source ↗
Our Earth We Now Lament to See Lyrics and Guitar Chords
Sheet Music
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Help Create More Free Teaching Resources
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us research more hymns and create additional teaching materials.