We Are One in the Spirit Meaning, History, and Theology
"We are one in the Spirit, we are one in the Lord"
- Written
- 1966
- Category
- Hymn
Viewed 49 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
We Are One in the Spirit, also known as They’ll Know We Are Christians by Our Love, was written by Roman Catholic priest Peter Raymond Scholtes in Chicago in 1966. Rooted especially in John 13:34-35, the song joins Christian unity with love, discipleship, and public witness.
Overview
We Are One in the Spirit is a modern Christian song about the visible consequences of belonging to Christ. Its central conviction is that unity in the Holy Spirit should become recognizable in the way Christians love, serve, and live together. The church’s witness is therefore not reduced to what it says about itself; it is tested by relationships that make the love of Christ perceptible to others.
The song joins ecclesiology with discipleship. Christian unity is a gift rooted in one Lord and one Spirit, but it also becomes a vocation requiring reconciliation, shared service, humility, and public faithfulness. This prevents unity from becoming either sentimental togetherness or mere organizational cooperation.
Pastorally, the hymn is especially useful for ecumenical worship, Pentecost, church anniversaries, reconciliation services, commissioning, mission, and gatherings concerned with racial or social division. Its historical setting gives those uses particular weight: it was written in Chicago for young singers participating in ecumenical and interracial events during the upheavals of the 1960s.
Historical Background
We Are One in the Spirit, more widely titled They’ll Know We Are Christians by Our Love, was written in 1966 by Peter Raymond Scholtes while he was a Roman Catholic priest at St. Brendan’s parish on Chicago’s South Side. The song belongs to the first generation of vernacular Catholic music that followed the Second Vatican Council, but its immediate purpose was unusually concrete. Scholtes was directing a youth choir and needed a suitable piece for a series of ecumenical and interracial events. His obituary, preserved by his family and colleagues, states that when he could not find an appropriate song, he wrote one himself in a single day.
That setting places the hymn at the intersection of several movements. Vatican II had encouraged fuller congregational participation and wider use of vernacular worship, while Chicago was experiencing intense racial tension, civil-rights organizing, and experiments in ecumenical cooperation. Scholtes’s later life showed that these concerns were not temporary. His obituary specifically notes that his experiences at St. Brendan’s and in the Chicago Civil Rights movement continued to influence him long after he left parish ministry.
The song was first published in Hymnal for Young Christians in 1966 by F.E.L. Publications. Hymnological sources identify Scholtes as both author and composer, and the tune is commonly named ST. BRENDAN’S after the parish context with which the song became associated. A 1968 recording produced by Scholtes with the young people of St. Brendan’s and local musicians helped carry the song beyond its original neighborhood. By 1969 it was already appearing in additional worship collections, and during the 1970s it spread rapidly through Catholic and Protestant congregational song.
Its ecumenical circulation is especially notable. Hymnary now indexes the text in roughly sixty hymnals, including Roman Catholic, Presbyterian, Methodist, Baptist, Anglican, Mennonite, Reformed, and other collections. The Worshipbook of 1972 associated it with Pentecost, ecumenism, World Communion, baptism, and the Lord’s Supper; later books such as The Faith We Sing, Glory to God, Gather, and Journeysongs placed it under themes of unity, church, discipleship, mission, and love.
The song also belongs to the folk-influenced musical culture of the 1960s. Scholtes wrote the melody at the same time as the text. Hymnologists describe its minor-mode or modal sound, pentatonic tendencies, and flattened seventh as features related to the folk idiom then common in youth and protest music. Guitar accompaniment became closely associated with the song, though later hymnals and choral arrangements adapted it for organ, piano, choir, handbells, and other ensembles.
The original words and music remain copyrighted. Early notices identify F.E.L. Publications, and later hymnal records state that the copyright was assigned to The Lorenz Corporation in 1991. Lorenz continues to publish arrangements of the work. Modern churches therefore need to distinguish between the historical significance of the 1966 song and the legal right to reproduce, project, arrange, record, or stream it.
Biblical Foundations
John 13:34-35 is the clearest biblical foundation for the song. Jesus commands his disciples to love one another and then makes that love a public sign of discipleship. Christian witness is therefore not limited to proclamation; the quality of relationships within the community becomes part of what the world is invited to see.
John 17:21 adds the missionary dimension of unity. Jesus prays that his followers may be one so that the world may believe. Unity is not an end in itself but is connected with the credibility of the church’s testimony to Christ.
Ephesians 4:3-6 and 1 Corinthians 12:12-13 ground unity in the work of the Spirit. The church is one body because believers share one Spirit, one Lord, one faith, and one baptism. Diversity of people and gifts does not disappear, but it is held within a deeper belonging created by God.
First John 4:11-12 explains why love must remain central. Christian love is a response to God’s prior love and becomes one way in which God’s presence is made visible in the community. This prevents the hymn’s call to love from being reduced to generic goodwill.
Verse Explanation
The song’s broad movement begins with the church’s unity in the Holy Spirit and develops that identity through shared discipleship. Unity is not left as an abstract doctrine; it becomes a pattern of common life in which Christians move, serve, and bear witness together.
The later movement turns from communal action toward praise, locating the church’s fellowship within the life and work of the Triune God. The recurring response then gives the entire song its ethical test: Christian identity should become recognizable through love.
The progression is therefore from identity to practice and from practice to witness. The song asks congregations not merely to affirm that they are one, but to live in such a way that their unity and love can be seen.
Theological Reflection
The song presents Christian unity as both gift and responsibility. The church does not create its deepest unity through institutional agreements, shared tastes, or social similarity; unity originates in the one Spirit and the one Lord. Yet believers are commanded to preserve and embody what God has given through humility, patience, reconciliation, and love.
Its theology of witness is equally important. John 13 links the identity of Jesus’ disciples with observable love, while John 17 links unity with the world’s response to the gospel. The church’s internal life therefore has missionary significance. Division, contempt, and indifference can contradict the message Christians proclaim, while truthful and costly love can make that message more credible.
The hymn also resists an individualistic understanding of discipleship. Faith is lived within a body whose members share responsibility for one another and participate together in God’s mission. Christian love must therefore move beyond private feeling toward concrete practices of service, dignity, cooperation, forgiveness, and solidarity.
The song’s ecumenical setting adds a useful qualification. Christian unity does not require pretending that theological differences are unimportant. Biblical unity is grounded in Christ and truth, but it also calls divided Christians to reject hostility and seek forms of fellowship, prayer, service, and reconciliation that faithfully express their common allegiance to Jesus Christ.
Church Impact
The song crossed denominational boundaries unusually quickly. From its Roman Catholic parish origin it entered ecumenical and Protestant collections within a few years and is now indexed by Hymnary in roughly sixty hymnals. Its circulation includes Catholic, Methodist, Presbyterian, Baptist, Anglican, Mennonite, Reformed, and independent evangelical traditions.
Editors have used it for Pentecost, Christian unity, ecumenism, fellowship, discipleship, mission, baptism, Communion, and services of sending. This breadth reflects the way the song links the Spirit, the church, love, and public witness without requiring a highly specialized liturgical setting.
Its history also illustrates the influence of post-Vatican II folk hymnody on broader contemporary worship. The combination of vernacular language, a memorable refrain, guitar-friendly harmony, and explicit social concern helped such songs move from Catholic youth settings into the developing repertoire of late twentieth-century congregational music.
Peter Scholtes’s own later career gives the song an unusual biographical afterlife. After leaving the priesthood he became an influential consultant and author concerned with humane cooperation, systems, leadership, and the dignity of people at work. That later work should not be read back into the 1966 text as its original meaning, but it is consistent with the lifelong concern for cooperation and human dignity that his obituary associates with his Chicago experience.
Musical Notes
Peter Scholtes wrote the melody at the same time as the text in 1966. The tune is commonly called ST. BRENDAN’S, though some hymnals identify it by the song title or first line. Hymnary commonly gives the meter as 7.6.7.6.8.6 with refrain, while some collections classify it more generally as irregular.
The tune is frequently printed in F minor. Carl P. Daw Jr. has noted its folk-derived pentatonic character and flattened seventh, features that connect it with the musical vocabulary of the 1960s. Its repeated melodic material and refrain make it easy for an assembly to learn, which suited the participatory aims of post-Vatican II worship and youth-oriented congregational music.
Historically, guitar accompaniment became strongly associated with the song, but the melody is adaptable. Later publishers have issued choral, organ, piano, handbell, and instrumental arrangements. These settings should be distinguished from Scholtes’s original melody because the arranger’s harmony, accompaniment, or additional material can carry its own copyright.
A moderate, steady tempo allows the communal character of the song to remain clear. Overly fast performance can turn a text about unity and shared discipleship into a slogan, while excessive heaviness can obscure the simplicity that made the melody effective for congregational participation.
Application
- Examine whether the congregation’s relationships make the love of Christ visible to people outside the church, especially in the way disagreement, conflict, and difference are handled.
- Pursue reconciliation where divisions have become habitual, while distinguishing genuine unity from avoiding difficult truths or suppressing legitimate differences.
- Create opportunities for Christians from different congregations, cultures, generations, and social backgrounds to pray and serve together around concrete needs.
- Treat every member of the church as part of one body, giving particular attention to people whose voices, gifts, or dignity are easily overlooked.
- Connect worship with public discipleship by asking how shared prayer and song will lead to shared service after the congregation leaves the sanctuary.
- Use authorized editions and licenses when reproducing, projecting, arranging, recording, or streaming the copyrighted song.
Discussion Questions
- Why does Jesus make love among his disciples a public sign by which others may recognize them?
- How does John 17 connect Christian unity with the church’s mission and credibility before the world?
- What is the difference between unity created by the Spirit and uniformity imposed by a group?
- How can Christians pursue visible unity while still taking theological truth and genuine disagreement seriously?
- What practices of reconciliation, shared service, and mutual dignity would make Christian love more observable in a local congregation?
- How does the song’s origin in ecumenical and interracial gatherings challenge churches facing divisions of race, class, culture, or denomination today?
Teaching Tips
- Begin with John 13:34-35 and John 17:21 so learners can see that the song’s themes of love and unity arise directly from Jesus’ teaching and prayer.
- Place the hymn in Chicago in 1966: Peter Scholtes was a Roman Catholic priest at St. Brendan’s, directing a youth choir and preparing for ecumenical and interracial events when he wrote the song in a single day.
- Explain that the words and music were both written by Scholtes and first published in Hymnal for Young Christians in 1966; ST. BRENDAN’S is not an older folk tune borrowed for the text.
- Use Ephesians 4:3-6 and 1 Corinthians 12:12-13 to distinguish Christian unity from sameness and to discuss how one body can contain diverse members and gifts.
- Discuss the civil-rights and ecumenical setting without romanticizing it; ask what visible forms of Christian solidarity are required in the congregation’s present context.
- Remind worship planners that the song remains copyrighted and that modern arrangements may carry additional rights.
Sources
-
Hymnal for Young Christians. F.E.L. Publications, Ltd., 1966, first publication of We Are One in the Spirit / They’ll Know We Are Christians by Our Love.
-
The Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology, article “They’ll Know We Are Christians by Our Love.”
-
Scholtes Seminars and Consulting, “Peter R. Scholtes, 1938–2009,” family and colleague obituary.
-
Taylor, Joshua. Discipleship Ministries, “History of Hymns: They’ll Know We Are Christians by Our Love,” 2019.
-
Daw, Carl P. Jr. Glory to God: A Companion. Westminster John Knox Press, 2016, notes on the text and ST. BRENDAN’S.
-
Hymnary.org, text authority page for We Are One in the Spirit / They’ll Know We Are Christians.
-
Hymnary.org, tune and hymnal-instance records for ST. BRENDAN’S and the 1966 copyright.
-
The Lorenz Corporation, official Peter Scholtes biography and current publications of They’ll Know We Are Christians.
-
American Society for Quality, Deming Medalists, listing Peter R. Scholtes as the 2006 recipient.
-
We Are One in the Spirit, 1968 recording produced by Peter Scholtes with the young people of St. Brendan’s Church, Chicago.
-
World English Bible, updated public-domain text from eBible.org.
Lyrics
Lyrics Not Displayed
This hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. To respect copyright, the full lyrics are not displayed here. HymnInfo still provides historical, biblical, and theological study notes where available.
Sheet Music
Music Sheet Not Displayed
This hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. To respect copyright, the full music sheet is not displayed here. Please use a licensed hymnal, authorized publisher, or approved sheet-music provider.
Looking for licensed sheet music? Use an authorized sheet-music provider or licensed hymnal for the complete music and text.
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Full lyrics and sheet music are not displayed because this hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. Teaching resources prepared for study and discussion may still be available below.
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us create more.
Opens in a new tab.