How Like a Gentle Spirit: History, Meaning, and Tune
"How like a gentle spirit deep within"
- Written
- 1987
- Category
- Hymn
- Tune
- SURSUM CORDA
Viewed 37 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
How Like a Gentle Spirit is C. Eric Lincoln's 1987 hymn on God's gentle strength, human unity, and love beyond race and sex. First published in The United Methodist Hymnal with Alfred Morton Smith's SURSUM CORDA, it joins inward spiritual formation with reconciliation and public witness.
Overview
How Like a Gentle Spirit is Charles Eric Lincoln's 1987 meditation on the character and work of God. It begins with divine presence experienced inwardly, yet it does not remain a private devotional text. God's gentle governance gives moral courage, confronts human pride, and summons worshipers toward a larger vision of humanity.
The hymn's controlling confession is that God's love transcends the categories by which people protect privilege or divide the human family. Gentleness is therefore not weakness. It is the steady divine power that disciplines destructive passion, exposes self-made images of God, and forms people for reconciliation.
Its themes make it suitable for services addressing God's nature, the Holy Spirit, Christian unity, confession, racial reconciliation, human dignity, and public witness. The hymn can lead a congregation from contemplation to self-examination and then to a renewed practice of courageous love.
Historical Background
How Like a Gentle Spirit arose directly from the preparation of The United Methodist Hymnal. In 1987 its revision committee invited thirteen poets to submit new texts employing a broad range of metaphors and images for God. Charles Eric Lincoln, then professor of religion and culture at Duke University, submitted three texts. The committee selected this one for the hymnal. No separate dramatic incident is documented as its inspiration; the securely attested occasion is the committee's invitation.
Lincoln welcomed the acceptance because he wanted to contribute to worship an understanding of both the uniqueness and universality of the Divine Being. That aim shaped the five-stanza text. It moves from God's inward moral influence to the unity of humankind, challenges attempts to fashion God after human prejudice or preference, and culminates in divine love that exceeds divisions of sex, race, culture, and place. Those themes closely connect the hymn with Lincoln's scholarly and pastoral work on race, the Black church, shared humanity, and reconciliation.
The first located publication is The United Methodist Hymnal, issued by The United Methodist Publishing House in 1989, where the hymn appears as number 115 in the section on God's nature. The book credits Lincoln's 1987 text and marks the words copyright 1989. The C. Eric Lincoln Collection at the Atlanta University Center also preserves a file describing a premiere at Duke Chapel on September 24, 1989, giving the hymn a documented early performance in Lincoln's own university setting.
The tune in the United Methodist record has a separate history. Alfred Morton Smith, an Episcopal priest, composed SURSUM CORDA in 1941. Hymnal records document it with Henry Montagu Butler's earlier text beginning Lift up your hearts in The Hymnal 1940. Smith's D-major tune and its meter of 10.10.10.10 therefore existed nearly five decades before Lincoln's words. The 1989 hymnal committee paired an established twentieth-century tune with the new text; Lincoln and Smith did not collaborate.
The hymn subsequently crossed several denominational and cultural settings. Lift Every Voice and Sing II included it in 1993 with Edward John Hopkins's ELLERS rather than SURSUM CORDA. Chalice Hymnal, Moravian Book of Worship, and The New Century Hymnal printed it in 1995, and The Covenant Hymnal followed in 1996, generally retaining Smith's tune. The 2001 Korean-English collection Come, Let Us Worship included a Korean translation with SURSUM CORDA. Zion Still Sings used Mark A. Miller's copyrighted tune BALTIMORE in 2007.
This reception shows modest but meaningful circulation rather than universal adoption. Hymnary indexes the text in nine collections, with several traditions using it to address God's nature, tenderness, courage, unity, conflict, and human dignity. The words remain copyrighted by The United Methodist Publishing House, and later tunes, translations, arrangements, and harmonizations may carry separate rights.
Biblical Foundations
John 16:13 and Romans 8:14 support the hymn's opening sense of divine guidance working within human life. The Spirit of truth does not merely soothe; the Spirit leads, corrects, and forms God's children. That biblical pattern helps explain why the hymn joins gentleness with courage and moral discipline.
Galatians 3:28 gives Christological grounding to the text's affirmation of human unity across inherited social divisions. Genesis 1:27 protects the dignity of women and men as bearers of God's image, while Acts 17:26 places every nation within one created human family. These passages challenge attempts to make God the possession or reflection of a favored group.
First John 4:16 supplies the hymn's theological center: God is love, and life in God is life within that love. Divine universality is therefore not vague tolerance but the outworking of God's own character, calling the church to truthful reconciliation and love that crosses boundaries.
Verse Explanation
The five-stanza text begins with God's gentle inward activity, but it immediately connects that presence with the governance of passion and the courage needed for a demanding moral path. The opening therefore establishes gentleness and strength as complementary rather than opposing qualities.
The middle movement widens the frame from the individual to the human family. It affirms a unity grounded in God's will and then confronts the human tendency to shrink God into an image that resembles and validates the worshiper's own interests. The imagery of divine formation makes people recipients of God's shaping work, not makers of a convenient deity.
The final movement applies this critique to persistent divisions, especially those associated with sex and race. It directs the congregation beyond competitive claims toward the universality of God's love. The progression is thus devotional, confessional, and social: inward guidance leads to the renunciation of idolatrous prejudice and to a more faithful vision of life together.
Because the text is copyrighted, this explanation intentionally describes its broad movement without reconstructing or closely paraphrasing each stanza. Worshipers should consult an authorized hymnal or licensed source for the complete words.
Theological Reflection
The hymn speaks about divine gentleness as active holiness. God works within human persons to restrain disordered desire and to give strength for faithful action. This is close to the Christian doctrine of sanctification: grace does not simply reassure but reforms the will, disciplines passion, and equips disciples for costly obedience.
Its language about God's image turns theology into self-examination. Human beings are made in God's image, yet sinful communities repeatedly reverse that relation by constructing a deity who approves their own race, sex, status, culture, or ideology. The hymn calls worshipers to receive God's self-disclosure rather than sanctify their preferences.
The affirmation of one human family also has ecclesial and social consequences. Unity does not erase history, culture, or difference, nor does it make injustice unreal. It denies that such distinctions can establish superior worth before God. Reconciliation therefore requires repentance, truthful attention to injury, and practices that honor the dignity of neighbors.
Finally, the hymn's confession of transcendent love resists both privatized spirituality and abstract universalism. The God who exceeds human categories also acts within human lives and communities. Divine love becomes credible in the church when inward formation produces courage, humility, solidarity, and a refusal to make prejudice sacred.
Church Impact
The hymn entered congregational print through The United Methodist Hymnal in 1989 and was placed among texts concerning God's nature. Its archival premiere at Duke Chapel that September connected the new hymnal text with Lincoln's academic and worshiping community. The record supports an identifiable launch, though it does not establish how frequently the hymn was sung afterward.
During the 1990s it appeared in an African American Episcopal collection, as well as Disciples of Christ, Moravian, United Church of Christ, and Evangelical Covenant hymnals. Editors classified it under the Holy Spirit, God's tenderness and image, courage, confession, conflict, unity, and human dignity. Those differing classifications show how the text could serve both theological reflection and socially engaged worship.
A Korean translation in the 2001 bilingual Come, Let Us Worship extended the text beyond English-only use, and Zion Still Sings gave it a new musical setting in 2007. Its impact is best described as cross-denominational and selective: it has supplied several traditions with a modern hymn joining contemplation of God to repentance from prejudice and a commitment to reconciliation.
Musical Notes
The United Methodist setting uses SURSUM CORDA, composed by Alfred Morton Smith in 1941. Its Latin name means Lift up your hearts, the traditional opening of the Eucharistic dialogue. The name also recalls the earlier text with which the tune appeared in The Hymnal 1940. It was not composed for Lincoln's hymn.
SURSUM CORDA is written for four ten-syllable lines, or 10.10.10.10, exactly matching Lincoln's stanza form. The United Methodist and many later hymnal instances print it in D major. Four balanced phrases give the substantial theological statements room to unfold, while the established tune supplies continuity for a text that asks worshipers to consider challenging social and spiritual claims.
A steady, unhurried tempo is preferable to either ponderousness or excessive brightness. Clear diction matters because each stanza develops an argument, and singers need enough forward movement to sustain the long lines. Accompaniment should support the textual progression and avoid obscuring it with excessive volume or rubato.
Other books demonstrate that the text is not inseparable from SURSUM CORDA. Lift Every Voice and Sing II used Edward John Hopkins's ELLERS in 1993, while Zion Still Sings paired the words with Mark A. Miller's BALTIMORE in 2007. Worship planners should identify the actual tune and harmonization in their source and credit each contributor accurately.
Application
- Examine which cultural, racial, political, or personal preferences are being mistaken for the character of God.
- Pair prayer for inward peace with one concrete act of courage on behalf of someone whose dignity is being diminished.
- Use the hymn during reconciliation work, allowing confession and careful listening to precede claims of unity.
- Teach Genesis 1:27 and Galatians 3:28 together so that shared dignity and unity in Christ inform the church's treatment of difference.
- Invite members to identify how the Spirit's gentle guidance may include correction, restraint, and changed behavior.
- Obtain permission for the copyrighted text and verify the rights attached to the selected tune, translation, harmonization, projection, or recording.
Discussion Questions
- Why does the hymn place gentleness and moral strength together rather than treating them as opposites?
- How can a community recognize when it has shaped its image of God around its own interests or prejudices?
- What do Genesis 1:27 and Galatians 3:28 affirm about dignity, difference, and unity?
- Why must reconciliation include repentance and truthful attention to injustice rather than a declaration that differences no longer matter?
- How might the Spirit's inward guidance change a congregation's public witness?
- What is gained or changed when this text is sung to SURSUM CORDA, ELLERS, or BALTIMORE?
Teaching Tips
- Explain that Lincoln wrote the hymn in response to a documented 1987 invitation from the United Methodist Hymnal Revision Committee, not because of an unverified dramatic event.
- Introduce Lincoln as a Methodist minister and major scholar of African American religion whose work gives historical weight to the hymn's concern for race and reconciliation.
- Read the text's biblical themes through 1 John 4:16, Galatians 3:28, Genesis 1:27, and Romans 8:14.
- Distinguish being made in God's image from the sinful habit of remaking God in humanity's preferred image.
- Compare the record's SURSUM CORDA setting with ELLERS or BALTIMORE if scores are legally available, asking how each tune shapes reception of the words.
- Use authorized hymnals or licenses for the text and verify permissions separately for translations, arrangements, projections, streams, and recordings.
Sources
-
Discipleship Ministries — C. Michael Hawn, History of Hymns: How Like a Gentle Spirit
View source ↗ -
Atlanta University Center, Robert W. Woodruff Library — C. Eric Lincoln Collection, finding aid
View source ↗ -
Atlanta University Center, Robert W. Woodruff Library — Duke Chapel premiere file for How Like a Gentle Spirit, September 24, 1989
View source ↗ -
Encyclopedia of Alabama — C. Eric Lincoln
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Text authority for How Like a Gentle Spirit
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — The United Methodist Hymnal 115 instance
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Tune authority for SURSUM CORDA by Alfred Morton Smith
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Alfred M. Smith person authority, citing The Presbyterian Hymnal Companion
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — The Hymnal 1940, number 482a, early SURSUM CORDA instance
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Lift Every Voice and Sing II, number 113, ELLERS setting
View source ↗ -
Hymnary.org — Zion Still Sings, number 97, BALTIMORE setting
View source ↗ -
World English Bible, Classic edition — public-domain Scripture text
View source ↗
Lyrics
Lyrics Not Displayed
This hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. To respect copyright, the full lyrics are not displayed here. HymnInfo still provides historical, biblical, and theological study notes where available.
Tune
Sheet Music
Music Sheet Not Displayed
This hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. To respect copyright, the full music sheet is not displayed here. Please use a licensed hymnal, authorized publisher, or approved sheet-music provider.
Looking for licensed sheet music? Use an authorized sheet-music provider or licensed hymnal for the complete music and text.
Learn This Hymn
Tune: SURSUM CORDA
Learn the Parts
Melody / Soprano
Alto
Tenor
Bass
Accompaniment Versions
Choose the accompaniment version that matches how many stanzas you plan to sing.
Standard Accompaniment
Help Keep These Hymn Recordings Free
Your support helps us continue creating accompaniment and SATB learning tracks for churches, choirs, and hymn learners.
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Full lyrics and sheet music are not displayed because this hymn is not currently marked as public domain in the HymnInfo database. Teaching resources prepared for study and discussion may still be available below.
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us create more.
Opens in a new tab.