Softly and Tenderly Jesus Is Calling Meaning, History, and Theology
"Softly and tenderly Jesus is calling"
- Written
- 1880
- Category
- Hymn
- Tune
- THOMPSON
- Status
- Published
- Rights
- Public domain
Viewed 294 times
Share this hymn
Help others discover the story, message, and study guide for this hymn.
Story
“Softly and Tenderly Jesus Is Calling” is an 1880 gospel invitation hymn for which Will Lamartine Thompson wrote both words and music. Sung to THOMPSON or SOFTLY AND TENDERLY, it joins Christ's gracious call with repentance, mercy, pardon, and the urgency of response.
Overview
“Softly and Tenderly Jesus Is Calling” is an invitation hymn built around a striking combination of gentleness and urgency. Christ is presented as the gracious one who summons weary and sinful people to return to God, while the worshiper is reminded that such a response should not be postponed indefinitely.
The hymn's pastoral strength lies in the way mercy frames repentance. The call to turn is not presented primarily through threat or coercion, but through welcome, patience, pardon, and rest. At the same time, the song does not treat repentance as optional or merely emotional; it asks hearers to respond while the opportunity remains.
That balance makes the hymn useful in evangelistic worship, confession, Lent, services of reconciliation, pastoral care, and occasions of renewed commitment. Its later association with funerals and memorials adds another layer of reception, but its primary historic function is the gospel invitation: hearing Christ's call and answering it with repentance and faith.
Historical Background
“Softly and Tenderly Jesus Is Calling” was written and composed by Will Lamartine Thompson and first published in 1880 in “Sparkling Gems Nos. 1 and 2 Combined,” issued by the Will L. Thompson Company in Chicago. The collection was edited by J. Calvin Bushey, a singing teacher and music compiler whose full name was James Calvin Bushey. This matters because some later internet accounts have incorrectly treated Bushey as one of Thompson's pseudonyms; hymnological authority records identify Bushey as a separate historical person who compiled several collections for Thompson's firm.
The hymn emerged from Thompson's unusual position as both creator and publisher. After encountering difficulty with established music publishers, he developed his own enterprise in East Liverpool, Ohio, later expanding into Chicago and selling not only sheet music and songbooks but also instruments and musical supplies. That business infrastructure gave Thompson a direct route for distributing his own sacred and secular work. In this case, the words and melody entered print together, so the familiar text-tune relationship is original rather than a pairing created by later hymnal editors.
The earliest form contains four stanzas and a refrain. Hymnary notes that the third stanza is frequently omitted in later collections, and some hymnals soften or revise one of its references to approaching death. Those editorial choices reveal a change in worship sensibility: the original revival song placed the brevity of life alongside divine mercy in order to intensify the call to respond, while some twentieth-century editors preferred less explicit mortality language.
Thompson's melody is generally known as THOMPSON or SOFTLY AND TENDERLY. Its triple meter, uncomplicated harmony, and flowing phrases support the restrained character of the invitation. Hymnal scholar Carlton R. Young compared its manner to a lullaby, a useful musical observation because the tune gives an evangelistic appeal an unusually caring rather than confrontational sound. The meter is normally indexed as 11.7.11.7 with refrain.
A famous story links the hymn with evangelist Dwight L. Moody. A later account repeated by hymn-story writer Ernest Emurian says that Thompson visited Moody near the end of the evangelist's life and received extraordinary praise for the song. The episode has been widely repeated, but no contemporary account has been located in the sources used here. It is therefore best treated as a later recollection, not as evidence for the hymn's origin or immediate reception.
The hymn eventually traveled far beyond the revival setting in which invitation songs flourished. It appears in hundreds of Methodist, Baptist, Presbyterian, Reformed, Lutheran, Mennonite, Adventist, African American, Salvation Army, Catholic, evangelical, and ecumenical collections. It was used at the memorial service for Martin Luther King Jr. at Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta on April 8, 1968, and later became a recurring musical element in the 1985 film “The Trip to Bountiful.” The 1880 words and music are public domain, although later arrangements, translations, revisions, recordings, and newly added material may have separate rights.
Biblical Foundations
Matthew 11:28 gives the hymn its clearest New Testament framework: Jesus calls burdened people to himself and promises rest. The invitation is personal and gracious, which helps explain why the hymn's tone is more pastoral than threatening.
Isaiah 55:6-7 adds repentance and pardon to the invitation. The prophet joins urgency with mercy: people are called to seek God and turn from sinful ways because God is ready to show mercy and freely pardon. This combination closely matches the hymn's balance of timely response and gracious welcome.
Mark 10:49 provides a vivid Gospel scene in which a person in need is told that Jesus is calling him. The verse should not be treated as a proven composition source, but it resonates strongly with the hymn's presentation of Christ as one who summons people personally and invites them to come.
Luke 15:7 places repentance within divine joy rather than humiliation. Heaven rejoices over the sinner who turns. Hebrews 3:15 supplies the sober counterpart: hearing God's voice calls for a response in the present rather than a hardened or indefinitely postponed answer.
Verse Explanation
The hymn follows a four-part invitational movement. It begins with Christ's gracious summons, then turns toward the danger of delaying a response, brings the finiteness of human life into view, and finally centers the appeal in divine love, mercy, and pardon.
The recurring refrain gives those movements a single liturgical purpose: hearing is meant to become response. The hymn therefore progresses from invitation through self-examination and urgency toward repentance, reconciliation, and renewed trust in Christ.
Theological Reflection
The hymn expresses a theology of grace in which the initiative belongs to Christ. The sinner is addressed because Christ calls, waits, and offers mercy. Human response matters, but it is response to a prior gracious summons rather than an attempt to persuade an unwilling God to forgive.
Repentance is therefore presented relationally. To turn from sin is also to return toward the One who welcomes. This protects the hymn from two opposite distortions: grace is not permission to remain unchanged, and repentance is not a work by which forgiveness is purchased.
The song also gives urgency a legitimate place in Christian proclamation. Human life is finite, habits of resistance can harden, and Scripture repeatedly uses the language of “today” when calling for faith and obedience. Yet urgency should not become manipulation. The hymn's own musical tenderness suggests that Christian invitation can be serious without exploiting fear or emotional pressure.
In traditions that speak of prevenient grace, the hymn can be heard as an especially clear picture of grace that seeks and summons before a person has made a saving response. Other traditions may frame the same movement differently, but the central theological pattern remains recognizable: Christ calls, mercy is offered, repentance is invited, and the hearer is urged not to remain distant.
Church Impact
The hymn became a durable part of English-language gospel-song repertory and is cataloged in hundreds of hymnals. Its circulation extends across Methodist, Baptist, Presbyterian and Reformed, Lutheran, Mennonite, Adventist, African American, Salvation Army, Catholic, evangelical, and other traditions. Hymnal editors variously place it under invitation, repentance, forgiveness, reconciliation, Lent, salvation, comfort, and Christian discipleship.
Its reception also expanded beyond the classic revival altar-call setting. Some hymnals omit the stanza that most directly emphasizes mortality, while others use the song in services of confession, healing, reconciliation, or remembrance. This editorial and liturgical flexibility has allowed the hymn to function both as an evangelistic summons and as a prayerful call to renewed faith among established Christians.
A documented moment in its twentieth-century history came at the memorial service for Martin Luther King Jr. at Ebenezer Baptist Church in Atlanta on April 8, 1968. The song later served as a recurring musical thread in the film “The Trip to Bountiful,” whose story of longing for home gave the hymn's invitation a poignant cultural setting.
Numerous translations and arrangements have extended its use beyond the original 1880 form. That continued transmission also requires copyright care: the historic Thompson text and melody are public domain, but a particular translation, harmonization, recording, arrangement, or revised edition may not be.
Musical Notes
Will L. Thompson composed the tune at the same time as the text, and both were published together in “Sparkling Gems Nos. 1 and 2 Combined” in 1880. The tune is commonly named THOMPSON or SOFTLY AND TENDERLY; some sources also identify it by the first line or with related descriptive titles. It is normally classified as 11.7.11.7 with refrain.
The tune is in triple meter and is commonly printed in 6/8. Hymnary gives G major in several representative modern settings, while other historic and modern editions use A-flat major. These differences are ordinary transpositions rather than separate melodies.
Its musical character is restrained for a revival invitation song. Flowing phrases, repeated rhythmic shapes, and straightforward harmony support congregational participation, while the refrain provides the principal point of emphasis. The lullaby comparison made by Carlton R. Young is musically helpful: the melody communicates patience and care even as the text presses for a decision.
A moderate, gently flowing tempo usually preserves that balance better than either a dragging sentimental performance or an aggressively dramatic altar-call style. Accompaniment should support clear communal singing and allow the refrain to intensify naturally without turning the invitation into theatrical pressure.
Application
- When inviting people to repentance, combine clarity about sin with the same patience, mercy, and welcome that the hymn associates with Christ.
- Use Matthew 11:28 when ministering to people burdened by guilt so that repentance is connected with coming to Christ rather than with endless self-punishment.
- Take delayed obedience seriously: identify one response to God that has repeatedly been postponed and bring it into prayer and accountable action.
- Create evangelistic and pastoral settings in which people can respond freely without coercive emotional pressure.
- In services of reconciliation, emphasize that return to God should lead toward restored relationships, truthful confession, and changed conduct.
- When using a modern arrangement or revision, distinguish Thompson's public-domain 1880 words and tune from later copyrighted material.
Discussion Questions
- How does the hymn hold together the tenderness of grace and the urgency of repentance?
- What does Matthew 11:28 reveal about the character of Christ's invitation to burdened people?
- How does Isaiah 55:6-7 prevent mercy from being separated from genuine turning toward God?
- Why can delay itself become a spiritual issue, and how does Hebrews 3:15 address it?
- How can churches invite people to faith or renewed commitment without using emotional coercion?
- What does the later omission or alteration of the mortality-focused stanza reveal about changing approaches to evangelistic hymnody?
Teaching Tips
- Establish the 1880 publication in “Sparkling Gems Nos. 1 and 2 Combined” and explain that Thompson wrote both the text and tune.
- Identify J. Calvin Bushey accurately as James Calvin Bushey, the singing teacher who compiled the collection, rather than repeating the unsupported claim that the name was merely a Thompson pseudonym.
- Read Matthew 11:28 and Isaiah 55:6-7 together to show that biblical invitation combines rest, repentance, mercy, and pardon.
- Explain the role of invitation songs in late nineteenth-century revival worship while distinguishing serious invitation from manipulative pressure.
- Present the Dwight L. Moody episode as a later hymn-story tradition rather than as a firmly documented contemporary event.
- Compare hymnals that retain or omit the mortality-focused stanza to discuss how editorial decisions can change a hymn's pastoral emphasis.
Sources
-
“Sparkling Gems Nos. 1 and 2 Combined,” edited by J. Calvin Bushey, Will L. Thompson & Company, Chicago, 1880, earliest located publication of Thompson's words and music.
-
The Canterbury Dictionary of Hymnology, articles “Softly and tenderly Jesus is calling” and “Will L. Thompson,” on first publication and Thompson's biography.
-
United Methodist Discipleship Ministries, C. Michael Hawn, “History of Hymns: Softly and Tenderly Jesus Is Calling,” on publication, gospel-song style, the later Moody tradition, the King memorial service, and later cultural use.
-
Hymnary.org, text authority page for “Softly and Tenderly Jesus Is Calling,” on authorship, four-stanza form, textual variants, Scripture associations, meter, public-domain status, and hymnal circulation.
-
Hymnary.org, tune authority and score for THOMPSON, on Will L. Thompson's 1880 melody, meter, triple-meter setting, keys, and public-domain status.
-
Hymnary.org, person authority page for Will L. Thompson, on his dates and work as a lyricist and composer.
-
Hymnary.org, person authority page for J. Calvin Bushey, identifying James Calvin Bushey as a singing teacher and compiler of “Sparkling Gems.”
-
Carlton R. Young, “Companion to The United Methodist Hymnal,” commentary on the tune's lullaby-like gospel-song character.
-
World English Bible, public-domain Scripture text.
Softly and Tenderly Jesus Is Calling Lyrics and Guitar Chords
Tune
Sheet Music
Learn This Hymn
Tune: THOMPSON
Learn the Parts
Melody / Soprano
Accompaniment Versions
Choose the accompaniment version that matches how many stanzas you plan to sing.
Standard Accompaniment
Help Keep HymnInfo Free
HymnInfo provides researched hymn histories, Scripture studies, recordings, sheet music, and teaching resources without charge. If this resource has helped you, your support helps us keep improving and expanding it.
Download Resources
Teaching and small-group resources available for this hymn.
Help Create More Free Teaching Resources
These teaching resources are free to use. Contributions help us research more hymns and create additional teaching materials.